DAPHNE DU MAURIER
ISBN U 582 419379
First published in the Longman Simplified English Series 1957
Chapter 1 Maxim de Winter 1
Chapter 2 Manderley 7
Chapter 3 The Cottage in the Bay 11
Chapter 4 The Shadow of Rebecca 19
Chapter 5 Rebecca’s Room 23
Chapter 6 The Fancy-Dress Dance 31
Chapter 7 The Sunken Boat 36
Chapter 8 The Inquiry 60
Chapter 9 Favell Accuses Maxim 64
Chapter 10 The Visit to Dr Baker 88
‘I was born on May 13th, 1907, into a world of make-believe and imagination,’ wrote Daphne du Maurier. Her father was Sir Gerald du Maurier, the leading actor and manager at Wyndham’s Theatre in London. Her mother, Muriel, was an actress and her grandfather, George du Maurier, was an artist and writer. So Daphne and her two sisters grew up in a world of writers and actors. She was educated at home, apart from six months spent in France when she was eighteen, and she read widely in English and French. Her first poems and stories were written while she was still a child.‘Books became my life … from the start I was always pretending to be someone else in a story’
In 1926 Daphne traveled with her mother and sisters to Fowey in Cornwall, and this visit seems to have been an important turning point in her life. She fell in love with the place and its people, and was moved to write her first full-length work of fiction. The Loving Spirit. This romantic story was read by Frederick Browning, who was then a young officer in the Guards. It touched him so deeply that he traveled to Fowey in his boat to meet the person who had written it.
In 1932 Browning and Daphne du Maurier were married. Du Maurier spent most of her adult life in the Cornwall which she loved so much and where her most popular books are set. She died there in 1989.
Du Maurier’s books can be divided into two main groups.
The first consists of historical fiction set in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century Cornwall; this includes Jamaica Inn (1936), Frenchman’s Creek (1941), Hungry Hill (1943) and The King’s
General (1946). These are romantic stories of adventure, violence and love. They show a strong longing for the past, but also a sense of how our present lives are affected by past events.
The second group are modern mystery stories, including Rebecca (1938), My Cousin Rachel (1951) and The Scapegoat (1957). In addirion, du Maurier wrote many books of short stories’. Two short stories, ‘The Birds’ and ‘Don’t Look Now’, were made into very successful films of the same names.
She also wrote non-fiction, including a book about her father’s life, the story of her own life, books about Cornwall, and a study of Branwell Bronte.
The work for which she is undoubtedly best known, though, is Rebecca. The book has always been extremely popular, and has appeared in over twenty languages. In 1940 it was made into a film starring Sir Laurence Ohvier and Joan Fontaine, directed by Alfred Hitchcock. At the heart of the story is a woman’s desire to please her husband and her feelings of hopelessness as she compares herself with his beautiful and highly educated first wife, in comparison with whom she feels plain and dull.
The dead wife seems to be always there in the background and to throw a dark shadow over her relationship with her new husband. The second wife, who tells the story, is never given a name, and this adds to the feeling that she is in the first wife’s rightful place.
Maxim de Winter is the owner of Manderley, a lovely country house by the sea. His beautiful wife Rebecca h^s died there, and Maxim goes to Monte Carlo after her death because he needs to get away. In Monte Carlo he meets an ordinary, unspoilt young woman, who is immediately attracted to him, and marries her. The weeks they spend in Monte Carlo together are extremely happy for the young woman, since she is very much in love. It is when she returns to Manderley with her husband that her problems begin. For some reason Mrs. Danvers, the housekeeper, takes an immediate dislike to the young wife.The young woman’s confidence is further shaken when Frank Crawley, who manages Mr de Winter’s business affairs, describes Rebecca as having been ‘the most beautiful creature I ever
saw in my fife”. Her dream of a happy life with her husband turns to horror as she begins to realise just how much influence the dead
woman still has.
Chapter 1 Maxim de Winter
Last night I dreamed I went to Manderley again. It seemed to me that I was passing through the iron gates that led to the driveway.
The drive was just narrow track now, its stony surface covered with grass and weeds. Sometimes, when I thought I had lost it, it would appear again, beneath a fallen tree or beyond a pool formed by the winter rains. The trees had thrown out new low branches which stretched across my way. I came to the house suddenly, and stood there with my heart beating fast and tears filling my eyes.
There was Manderley, our Manderley, secret and silent as it had always been, the grey stone shining in the moonlight of my dream. Time could not spoil the beauty of those walls, nor of the place itself, as it lay like a jewel in the hollow of a hand. The grass sloped down towards the sea, which was a sheet of silver lying calm under the moon, like a lake undisturbed by wind or storm.
I turned again to the house, and I saw that the garden had run wild, just as the woods had done. Weeds were everywhere. But moonlight can play strange tricks with the imagination, even with a dreamer’s imagination.As I stood there, hushed and still, I could swear that the house was not an empty shell but lived and breathed as it had lived before. Light came from the windows, the curtains blew softly in the night air, and there, in the library, the door stood half open as we’d left it, with my handkerchief on the table beside the bowl of autumn flowers.
Then a cloud came over the moon, like a dark hand across a face.The memories left me. I looked again at an empty shell, with no whisper of the past about its staring walls. Our fearand suffering were gone now. When I thought about Manderley in 31 in my waking hours I would not be bitter; I would think of it as it  might have been, if I could have lived there without fear. I would remember the rose garden in summer, and the birds that sang
there; tea under the trees, and the sound of the sea coming up to us
from the shore below. I would think of the flowers blown from the
bushes, and the Happy VaUey. These things could never lose their
freshness. They were memories that could not hurt. All this I knew
in my dream (because, like most sleepers, I knew that I dreamed).
In reality, I lay far away, in a foreign land, and would wake before
long in my lonely little hotel bedroom. I would lie for a moment,
stretch myself and turn, confused by that burning sun, that hard,
clean sky, so different from the soft moonlight of my dream. The
day would lie before us both, long no doubt, but full of a certain
peace, a calm we had not known before. We would not talk of
Manderley; I would not tell my dream. For Manderley was ours no
longer. Manderley was no more.
We can never go back again; that is certain. The past is still too
close to us. But we have no secrets from each other now;
everything is shared. Our little hotel may be dull, and the food not
very good; day after day, things may be very much the same. But
dullness is better than fear. We live now very much by habit. And I
have become very good at reading out loud. The only time I have
known him show impatience is when the postman is delayed and
we have to wait for our post from England. I have lost my old
self-consciousness. I am very different from that person who drove
to Manderley for the first time, hopeful and eager, filled with the
desire to please. It was my lack of confidence, of course, that struck
people like Mrs Danvers. What’ must I hjve seemed like, after
I can see myself now, so long ago, with my short straight hair
and young, unpowdered face, dressed in a badly fitting coat and
skirt, following Mrs Van Hopper into the hotel for lunch. She
would go to her usual table in the corner, near the window, and,
looking to left and right, would say, ‘Not a single well-known
face! I shall tell the manager he must make a reduction in my bill.
What does he think I come here for? Tp look at the waiters?’
We ate in silence, as Mrs Van Hopper liked to think about
nothing but her food. Then I saw that the table next to ours, which
had been empty for three days, was to be used once more. The head
.waiter was showing the new arrival to his place. Mrs Van Hopper
put down her fork and stared. Then she leaned over the table to me,
her small eyes bright with excitement, her voice a little too loud.
‘It’s Max de Winter,’ she said,‘the man who owns Manderley.
You’ve heard of it, of course. He looks ill, doesn’t he? They say he
hasn’t been the same since his wife’s death. The papers were full of
it, of course. They say he never talks about it, never mentions her
name. She was drowned, you know, in the bay near Manderley .. .’
Her interest in other people was like a disease. I can see her as
though it were yesterday, on that unforgettable afternoon,
wondering how to make her attack. Suddenly, she turned to me.
‘Go upstairs quickly and find that letter from my brother’s son, the
one with the photograph. Bring it dovvn to me immediately.’
I saw then that she had made her plan. I wished I had the
courage to warn the stranger. But when I returned, I saw that she
had not waited; he was already sitting beside her. I gave her the
letter, without a word. He rose to his feet immediately.
‘Mr de Winter is having coffee with us; go and ask the waiter for
another cup,’ she said, just carelessly enough to warn him what I
was. Her expression showed that I was young and unimportant, and
that there was no need to include me in the conversation. So it was
a surprise when he remained standing and made a sign to the
‘I’m afraid I must disagree,’ he said to her.‘You are both having
coffee with me,’ and before I knew what had happened he was
sitting on my usual chair and I was beside Mrs Van Hopper.
For a moment she looked annoyed. Then she leaned forward,
holding the letter.
‘You know, I recognized you as soon as you walked in,’ she said,
‘and I thought, “Why, there’s Mr de Winter, Billy’s friend; I simply
must show him the photographs of Billy and his wife.” And here
they are, bathing at Palm Beach. Billy is mad about her. He hadn’t
met her, of course, when he gave that party where I saw you first.
But I don’t expect you remember an old woman like me?’
‘Yes, I remember you very well,’ he said.’l don’t think 1 should
care for Palm Beach. That sort of thing has never amused me.’
Mrs Van Hopper gave her fat laugh. ‘If Billy had a home like
Manderley, he wouldn’t want to play around in Palm Beach,’ she
said. She paused, expecting him to smile, but he went on smoking,
looking just a little disturbed.
‘I’ve seen pictures of it, of course,’ she said, ‘and it looks
perfectly beautiful. I remember Billy telhng me it was lovelier than
any other house of its size and age. I am surprised you can ever bear
to leave it.’
His silence was painful, as anyone else would have noticed, but
she continued, ‘You Englishmen are all the same about your
homes,’ her voice becoming louder, ‘you don’t want to seem proud
of them. Isn’t there a great haU at Manderley, with some very
I think he realized my discomfort; he leaned forward in his
chair and spoke to me, his voice gentle, asking if I would have some
more coffee, and when 1 shook my head I felt that his eyes were
still resting on me, wondering.
‘What brings you here?’ Mrs Van Hopper went on.‘You’re not
one of the regular visitors. What are your plans?’
‘I haven’t made up my mind,’ he said,‘I came away in rather a
His own words must have raised a memory, for he looked
disturbed again. She talked on, still not noticing. ‘Of course you
miss Manderley.The West Country must be lovely in the spring.’
‘Yes,’ he said shortly. ‘Manderley was looking its best.’
In the end it was a waiter who gave him his opportunity, with a
message for Mrs Van Hopper. He got up immediately, pushing back
his chair. ‘Don’t let me keep you,’ he said.
‘It’s so nice to have met you like this, Mr ,de Winter; I hope I
shall see something of you.You must come and have a drink some
time. I have one or two people coming in tomorrow evening. Why
not join us?’ Г turned away so that I did not have to watch him
search for an excuse.
‘I’m so sorry,’ he said, ‘tomorrow I am probably driving to Sospel;
I’m not sure when I shall get back.’
Looking a little annoyed, she left it, and he went.
The next morning Mrs Van Hopper woke with a sore throat and a
rather high temperature. Her doctor told her to stay in bed. I left
her quite happy, after the arrival of a nurse, and went down early
for lunch — a good half-hour before our usual time. I expected the
room to be empty, and it was — except for the table next to ours. I
was not prepared for this. I thought he had gone to Sospel. I was
halfway across the room before I saw him, and could not go back.
This was a situation for which I was not trained. I wished I was
older, different. I went to our table, looking straight ahead. But as
soon as 1 sat down, I knocked over the bowl of flowers. The water
ran over the cloth, and down onto my legs.The waiter was at the
other end of the room and did not see. In a second, though, my
neighbou/ was at my side.
‘You can’t sit with a wet tablecloth,’ he said,‘you won’t enjoy
your food. Get out of the way’ He began to dry the table with his
handkerchief, and then the waiter came hurrying to help.
‘Lay my table for two,’ he said. ‘This lady will have lunch with
‘Oh, no,’ I said,‘I couldn’t possibly.’
I tried to think of an excuse. 1 knew he did not want to lunch
with me. He was only being polite.
‘Come and sit down. We needn’t talk unless we want to.’
He sat down, and went on eating, his lunch as though nothing
had happened. I knew we could go on like this, all through the.
meal, without speaking but without any sense of awkwardness.
‘Your friend,’ he began at last,‘she is very much older than you.
Have you known her long?’
‘She’s not really a friend,’ I told him, ‘she is an employer. She’s
training me to be a companion, and she pays me.’
‘1 did not know one could buy companionship,’ he said; ‘it
sounds a strange idea. You haven’t much in common with her.
What do you do it for? Haven’t you any family?’
‘No – they’re dead.’
‘You know,’ he said,‘we’ve got that in common, you and I. We
are both alone in the world. Oh, I’ve got a sister, though we don’t
see much of each other, and an ancient grandmother whom I visit
two or three times a year, but neither of them provides much
companionship. You know, I think you’ve made a big mistake in
coming here, in joining forces with Mrs Van Hopper. You’re not
made for that sort of job. You’re too young, for one thing, and too
soft. Now go upstairs and put your hat on, and I’ll have the car
I was happy that afternoon; I can remember it well. I can see the
blue sky and sea. I can feel again the wind on my face, and hear my
laugh, and his that answered it. It was not the Monte Carlo that I
had known before. The harbour was a dancing thing, bright with
boats, and the sailors were cheerful, smiling men, careless as the
wind. 1 can remember as though I were still wearing it my
comfortable, badly fitting suit, my broad hat, the shoes I wore. 1
had never looked more youthful; 1 had never felt so old.
I am glad it cannot happen twice, the fever of first love. For it is a
fever, and a misery too, whatever the poets may say. One is so easily
I have forgotten much of Monte Carlo, of those morning drives, of
where we went, even of our conversation; but I have not forgotten
how my fingers trembled, pulling on my hat, and how I would run
down the stairs and so outside. He would be there, in the driver’s
seat, reading a paper while , he waited, and when he saw me he
would smile, and throw it behind him into the back seat, and open
the door, saying,‘Well, how is the companion this morning, and
where does she want to go?’ If he had driven round in circles it
would not have mattered to me.
Chapter 2 Manderley
We came to Manderley in early May, arriving, so Maxim said, with
the birds and the flowers before the start of summer. I can see
myself now, badly dressed as usual, although I had been married for
seven weeks. I wondered if he guessed that I feared my arrival at
Manderley now as much as I had looked forward to it before. Gone
was my excitement, my happy pride. I was like a child brought to
her first school. Any confidence I had gained during my seven
weeks of marriage was gone now.
‘‘You mustn’t mind if there’s a certain amount of interest in you,’
he said.‘Everyone will want to know what you are like.They have
probably talked of nothing else for weeks. You’ve only got to be
yourself and they will all love you. And you won’t have to worry
about the house; Mrs Danvers does everything. Just leave it all to
her. She’ll be stiff with you at first, I expect. She’s an unusual
character, but you mustn’t let her worry you.’
We drove through two high iron gates ancf up the long
driveway. We stopped at the wide stone steps at the open door, and
two servants came down to meet us.
‘Well, here we are. Frith,’ said Maxim to the older one, taking
ofFhis hat.‘And this is Robert,’ he added, turning towards me. We
walked together up the steps, Frith and Robert following with my
coat and travelling bag.
‘This is Mrs Danvers,’ said Maxim.
Someone came forward from the sea of faces, someone tall and
thin, dressed in black, with great dark eyes in a white face. When
she took my hand, hers was heavy and deathly cold and it lay in
mine like a lifeless thing. Her eyes never left mine. l cannot
remember her words now, but I know she welcomed me to
Manderley, in a stiff little speech spoken in a voice as cold and
lifeless as her hand had been. When she had finished, she waited, as
though for a reply, and I tried to say something, dropping my hat in
my confusion. She bent to pick it up, and as she handed it to me I
saw a little smile of scorn on her lips.
After tea Frith came in. ‘Mrs Danvers wondered, madam,
whether you would like to see your room.’
Maxim looked up.‘How did they get on with the east wing?’ he
‘Very well, sir. Mrs Danvers was rather afraid it would not be
finished by your return. But the men left last Monday. I think you
will be very comfortable, sir; it’s a lot lighter, of course, on that side
of the house.’
‘What have they been doing?’ 1 asked.
‘Oh, nothing much. Only redecorating and changing the furniture in
the rooms in the east wing, which I thought we would use for ours. As
Frith says, it’s much more cheerful on that side of the house, and it has a
lovely view of the rose garden. It. was the visitors’ wing when my mother
was alive. I’ll just finish reading these letters and then I’ll come up and
join you. Run
along and make friends with Mrs Danvers. It’s a good opportunity.’
The black figure stood waiting for me at the top of the stairs, her
dark eyes watching me from her pale face. We went along broad
passages, then came to a door which she opened, standing back to
let me pass.There was a large double bedroom with wide windows,
and a bathroom on the far side. I went straight to the windows. The
rose garden lay below, and, beyond it, a smooth grass bank
stretching to the woods. ^
‘You can’t see the sea from here, then,’ I said, turning to Mrs
‘No, not fix)m this wing,’ she answered,‘you can’t even hear it.
You would not know the sea was anywhere near, from this wing.’
She spoke in a strange way, as though something lay behind her
words – as though there was something wrong with this wing.
‘I’m sorry about that; I like the sea.’
She did not answer; she just went on looking at me, her hands
folded in front of her.
‘But it’s a very beautiful room, and I’m sure we shall be very
comfortable. I understand that it has been redecorated.
‘What was it like before?’
‘There was, blue paper on the walls, and there were different
curtains. Mr de Winter did not find it very cheerful. It was never
used much, except for occasional visitors. But Mr de Winter gave
special orders in his letter that you were to have this room.’
‘Then this was not his bedroom originally?’
‘No, madam; he’s never used the rooms in this wing before.’
‘Oh. He didn’t teh me that.’
There was silence between us. I wished she would go away. 1
wondered why she had to go on standing there, watching me, her
hands folded on her black dress.
‘I suppose you have been at Manderley for many years,’ 1 satd,
making another effort, ‘longer than anyone else?’
‘Not so long as Frith,’ she said, and I thought again how lifeless
her voice was, and how cold; ‘Frith was here when the old
gentleman was living, when Mr de Winter was a boy.’
‘I see; so you did not come until after that.’
‘No. Not until after that. I came here when Mr de Winter
married his first wife,’ she said, and her voice, which had been dull
and flat, was suddenly filled with unexpected life, and there was a
spot of colour in her bony face. The change was so sudden that 1
was disturbed. I did not know what to do or to say. It was as though
she had spoken words which were forbidden, words which she had
hidden within herself for a long time and now would be kept in no
longer. I could see that she scorned me, seeing that I was no great
lady, but was ordinary and awkward.Yet there was something
beside scorn in those eyes of hers, something surely of positive
dislike, or actual hatred?
I had to say something; I could not let her see how much I feared
and mistrusted her.
‘Mrs Danvers,’ I heard myself saying,‘I hope we shall be friends
and come to understand one another. You must have patience with
me, you know, because this sort of life is new to me; I’ve lived
rather differently. But I do want to make a success of it, and above
all to make Mr de Winter happy. I know I can leave arrangements
in the house to you, and you must just run things as they have
always been run! I shan’t want to make any changes.’ I stopped,
rather breathless, and when I looked up again I saw that she had
moved, and was standing with her hand on the handle of the door.
‘Very good,’ she said; ‘I hope I shall do everything to your
satisfaction. The house has been in my charge now for more than a
year, and Mr de Winter has never complained. It was very different
of course when the first Mrs de Winter was alive; there
were many visitors then, a lot of parties, and though I managed
things for her, she liked to give the orders herself.’
Once again I felt that she chose her words with care, and was
watching for their effect on my face.
‘1 would rather leave it to you,’ I repeated, ‘much rather,’ and
into her face came the same expression I had noticed before, when I
first shook hands with her in the hall, a look of scorn. I wished she
would go; she was like a shadow standing there.
‘If you find anything not to your liking, you will tell me
‘Yes,’ I said, ‘yes, of course, Mrs Danvers,’ but I knew this was
not what she had meant to say, and silence fell between us once
‘Dislike you? Why dislike you? What the devil do you mean?’ He
turned from the window, an angry look on his face. 1 wondered
why he should mind, and wished 1 had said something else.
‘I mean, it must be. much easier for her to look after a man alone.
1 expect she had got used to doing it, and perhaps she was afraid I
would be difficult.’
‘Difficult, my God …’ he began, ‘if you think …’ and then he
stopped, and kissed me on the top of my head.
‘Let’s forget about Mrs Danvers,’ he said; ‘she doesn’t interest me
very much. Come along, and let me show you something of
Chapter 3 The Cottage in the Bay
I had never realized that life at Manderley would be so orderly and
planned. 1 remember now, looking back, how on that first morning
Maxim was up and dressed/and writing letters even
before breakfast, and how when I came downstairs I found he had
nearly finished. He looked up at me and smiled.
‘You mustn’t mind,’ he said, ‘this is somfthing you must get used
to. Running a place like Manderley is hard work. By the way, my
sister Beatrice has written to ask her husband Giles and herself over
to lunch. I half expected she would. I suppose she wants to have a
look at you.’
‘Today?’ I said, my heart sinking.
‘Yes. She won’t stay long. You’ll like her, I think. She’s very
honest. If she doesn’t like you, she’ll tell you so to your face.’
I found this hardly comforting.
‘I’ve a lot of things to deal with this morning. I must see Frank
Crawley, who looks after my affairs. I’ve been away too long. Ле’11
be in to lunch too, by the way.’Then he picked up his letters and
went out of the room, and I remember thinking that this was not
how I had imagined my first morning.
After lunch Beatrice and I went out, and walked around slowly on the
smooth green grass.
‘I think it’s a pity you came back to Manderley so soon,’ said
Beatrice,‘it would have been far better to travel in Italy for three or
four months, and come back in the middle of the summer. It would
have done Maxim good too, besides being ea.sier for you. I can’t
help feeling that it’s going to be rather difficult for you here at first.’
‘Oh, I don’t think so,’ I said. ‘I know 1 shall learn to love
She did not answer, and we walked up and down across the
‘Tell me a bit about yourself,’ she said at last;‘what was it you
were doing in the south of France? Living with some terrible
American woman, Maxim said.’
I explained about Mrs Van Hopper, and what had led to it, and
she seemed sympathetic but distant, as though she were thinking of
‘Yes,’ she said.‘It all happened very suddenly. But of course we
were all very pleased, my dear, and I do hope you will both be
I wondered why she said she hoped we would be happy, instead
of saying she knew we would be so. She was kind, she was sincere, 1
liked her very much, but there was a shade of doubt in her voice
that made me feel afraid.
‘Poor Maxim,’ she said, ‘he went through a terrible time, and let’s
hope you have made him forget about it.We are not a bit like each
other. I show everything on my face – whether I like people or not,
whether I am angry or pleased. Maxim is completely different. Very
quiet. You never know what’s going on in that funny mind of his. I
lose my temper easily, quarrel hard, and then it’s all over. Maxim
loses his temper once or twice in a year — and when he does, he
really loses it. I don’t suppose he ever will with you; I should think
you are a calm little thing.’
She looked away from me, her hands in her pockets, and
examined the house in front of us.
‘You’re not using the west wing, then?’ she said.
‘No. We are in the east wing. It has all been got ready specially.’
‘Has it? I didn’t know that. I wonder why.’
‘It was Maxim’s idea. He seems to prefer it.’
She said nothing, but went on looking at the windows. ‘How do
you get on with Mrs Danvers?’ she asked suddenly.
‘I haven’t seen much of her. She frightens me a bit. I’ve never
seen anyone quite like her before.’
‘I don’t suppose you have,’ said Beatrice.‘There’s no need to be
frightened of her, and don’t let her see it, whatever you do. Did she
‘No, not very’
‘I shouldn’t have more to do with her than you can help. Of
course she’s madly jealous. I was afraid she would be.’
‘Why? Why should she be jealous? Maxim doesn’t seem to be
particularly fond of her.’
‘My dear child, it’s not Maxim .she’s thinking of. No. She dislikes
your being here at all – that’s the trouble.’
‘Why? Why should she dislike me?’
‘I thought you knew. I thought Maxim would have told you. She
loved Rebecca so much.’
‘Oh,’ I said. ‘Oh, 1 see.’
When the Lacys were leaving, Beatrice took my hand, then,
bending down, gave me a quick kiss.‘Goodbye,’ she said.‘Forgive
me if I’ve asked you a lot of rude questions, my dear, and said all
sorts of things I shouldn’t. Politeness never was my strong point, as
Maxim will tell you. And you’re not a bit what 1 expected.’ She
looked straight at me.‘You see,’ she said, starting towards the door,
‘you’re so different from Rebecca.’
We watched the car disappear round the curve of the drive, and
then Maxim took my arm and said,‘Thank goodness for that! Get a
coat quickly, and come out – never mind the rain; I want a walk. I
can’t stand sitting around.’
He called to his dog, Jasper, and we headed towards the sea. We soon
came to a place in the woods where there were two paths leading in
different directions.The dog took the right-hand path. ‘Not that way,’
called Maxim,‘come on, Jasper, old boy!’
The dog looked back at Us, but did not move.
‘Why does he want to go that way?’ I asked.
‘I suppose he’s used to it,’ said Maxim; ‘it leads to a little bay,
where we used to keep a boat. Come on, boy! Jasper!’
We turned onto the left-hand path.
‘This brings us to what we call the Happy Valley. There! Look at
We stood on the slope of a wooded hill, and the path ran on
ahead of us into a vaUey, by the side of a running stream. On either
side were flowering bushes, pink, white and gold, bending their
heads in the summer rain. The air was full of their lovely smells.
We wandered down into the valley. At the end of the path the
flowers joined above our heads. We bent down to pass under them,
and when I stood straight again, brushing the raindrops from my
hair, I saw that we were standing in a little bay, the stones hard and
white under our feet and the waves breaking on the shore beyond
us. Maxim smiled down at me, watching my face,
‘It’s a surprise, isn’t it?’ he said.‘No one ever expects it. It’s so
We walked on the shore, playing with the dog and throwing
stones into the sea. Then we looked round, and found that Jasper
had disappeared. We called and whistled, but he did not come.
Then, beyond the rocks to the right of the bay, I heard him.
‘Hear that? He’s over that way’ I began to climb over the slippery
‘Come back!’ said Maxim sharply. ‘We don’t want to ‘go that
way. The fool of a dog must look after himself He knows his own
I pretended not to hear, and went on as best I could, climbing
and slipping over the wet rocks. Then, looking up, I saw with
surprise that I was in another bay. A stone wall had been built out
from it to form a little harbour. Where the woods riiet the shore
there was a long low building, half boathouse, half cottage, built of
the same stone as the sea wall. There was a man on the beach, a
fisherman perhaps, in long boots, and Jasper was running round
and jumping at him. But the man took no notice; he was bending
down, digging among the stones.
The man looked up at the sound of my footsteps.
‘Good day,’ he said. ‘Dirty, isn’t it?’
He had small eyes, a red, wet mouth and an empty foolish face.
He watched me with interest, smiling all the time. ‘Digging for
shells,’ he said. ‘No shells here. Been digging ever since the morning.’
‘Oh,’ I said.‘I’m sorry you can’t find any.’
‘That’s right. No shells here.’
‘Come on, Jasper,’ I said,‘it’s getting late. Come on, old boy!’
But Jasper was noisy and stupid, running round after nothing at
all, excited perhaps by the wind and the sea. I saw that he would
never follow me. I turned to the man, who had bent down again to
his useless digging.
.‘Have you got any string?’
‘Have you got any string?’
‘No shells here. Been digging since morning.’ And he wiped his
pale blue watery eyes.
‘I want some string for the dog. He won’t follow me.’
‘Eh?’ he said, and smiled his foolish smile.
‘Ah right. It doesn’t matter.’
I wondered if there was any string in the boathouse, and walked
to it. To my surprise, the door was not locked, so I went inside,
expecting to find the usual nets and boating equipment. But I was
in a proper room, with tables, chairs and a bed pushed against the
wall. There were bookshelves, with books in them, cups and plates,
and on the shelves little model ships. But no one lived here. It Was
cold, and very dusty. I did not like it. I opened a door at the end of
the room. Here were the ropes I had expected, a sail or two, paint
pots, and on a shelf a ball of string and an old knife. They would do.
When I came out of the cottage, not looking behind me, the
man was not digging any more; he was watching me, Jasper at his
side. I bent down and this time Jasper aUowed me to tie the string
to his collar.
‘I saw you go in there,’ the man said, starij^ at me with his
narrow watery eyes.
‘Yes. It’s all right. Mr de Winter won’t mind.’ .
‘She don’t go in there now,’ he said.
‘She’s gone in the sea, hasn’t she? She won’t come back no
‘No. She’ll not come back.’
‘I never said nothing, did I?’
‘No, of course not; don’t worry.’
He bent down again to his digging, talking quietly to himself. I
went across the stones and saw Maxim waiting for me by the rocks,
his hands in his pockets.
‘I’m sorry,’ I said. ‘Jasper wouldn’t come. I had to get some
He turned sharply, and started towards the woods.
‘I’m sorry I was such a time. It was Jasper’s fault. He kept
running round the man. Who was he?’
‘Only Ben. He’s quite harmless, poor devil. His father was one of
the farm servants. Where did you get that string?’
‘I found it in the cottage.’
Maxim did not reply. He walked very fast, and the path was
‘Come on, Jasper! Make him walk faster, can’t you? Pull that
‘It’s your fault. You’re walking so quickly. We can’t keep up
‘If you had listened to me instead of rushing off over those rocks,
we would have been home by now. Jasper knew his way back. I
can’t think what you wanted to go after him for.’
‘I thought he might have fallen and hurt himself. And I was
afraid of the tide.’
‘Is it likely that I would have left the dog if there had been any
danger from the tide? I told you not to go on those rocks, and ndw
you’re complaining because you’re tired.’
‘Anyone would be tired, walking at this speed. 1 thought you’d
come with me when 1 went after Jasper, instead of staying behind.’
‘Why should I run after the miserable dog?’
‘You just say that because you haven’t got any other excuse.’
‘Excuse for what?’
‘Excuse for not coming with me over the rocks.’
‘Well, and why do you think 1 didn’t want to cross to the other
‘Oh, Maxim — how should I know? I’m not a mind reader. 1
know you didn’t want to, that’s all. I could see it in your face.’
‘See what in my face?’
‘I’ve already told you. I could see that you didn’t want to go.’
‘All right — I didn’t want to go to the other bay.Will that please
you? I never go near the place, or that miserable cottage. And if you
had my memories you would not want to go there either, or talk
about it, or even think about it. There! I hope that satisfies you.’
His face was white, his eyes watering, with that dark, lost look
they had had when I first met him. I put out my hand to his and
held it tight.
‘Please, Maxim, please!’ I said.
‘What’s the matter?’ he answered roughly.
‘I don’t want you to look like that. It hurts too much. Please,
Maxim. Let’s forget everything we said. A stupid, senseless
argument. I’m sorry, dear. I’m sorry. Please let everything be all
‘We ought to have stayed in Italy,’ he said.‘We ought never to
have come back to Manderley. Oh God, what a fool I was to come
Chapter 4 The Shadow of Rebecca
The next day I met Frank Crawley on the drive. He took off his hat
and smiled. He seemed glad to see me. I smiled back at him. It was
nice of him to be glad to see me. I liked Frank Crawley. I did not
find him dull, as Beatrice did. Perhaps it was because 1 was dull
myself. We walked along together.
‘I was down in one of the bays the other day,’ I said, ‘the one
with the little harbour. Jasper was behaving badly, running round
that poor man who seems so foolish.’
‘You must mean Ben. He’s always on the shore. He’s quite a nice
person; you need never be frightened of him. He would not hurt a
‘Oh, I wasn’t frightened,’ I said. I waited a moment, to gain
confidence. ‘I’m afraid that cottage place will be ruined,’ I said
lightly. ‘I had to go in to find a bit of string to tie up Jasper. It’s so
cold and wet that the books are all getting spoilt. Why isn’t
something done about it? It seems such a pity.’
I knew he would not answer immediately. He bent down to tie
up his shoe. ‘I think if Maxim wanted anything done, he would tell
‘Are they aU Rebecca’s things?’
‘What did she use the cottage for? It looked quite lived-in. I
thought from the outside it was just a boathouse.’
‘It was a boathouse originally’ He sounded uncomfortable. ‘Then
– then she changed it .. . had furniture put in, and books.’
‘Did she use it much?’
‘Yes, she did. For moonlight swims and — and one thing and
‘What fun! Moonlight swimming must be lovely. Did you ever
‘Once or twice.’
1 pretended not to notice how quiet he had become; he clearly
did not want to speak about these things.
‘What is the little harbour for?’
‘The boat used to be kept there.’
A strange sort of excitement was on me. I had to go on with my
questions. He did not want to talk about it. I knew that. But I could
not be silent.
‘What happened to it? Was that the boat she was sailing when
she was drowned?’
‘Yes. It turned over and sank. She was washed overboard.’
‘What sort of size was it?’
‘Pretty small. It had a little place to sleep in.’
‘What made it turn over?’
‘It can be very windy in the bay’
‘Couldn’t someone have got out to her?’
‘Nobody saw the accident; nobody knew she had gone.’
‘They must have known up at the house!’
‘No. She often went out alone like that. She would come back at
any time of night, and sleep at the cottage on the shore.’
‘Did — did Maxim mind hef going off alone like that?’
He waited a minute, and then shook his head. ‘I don’t know,’ he
said shortly. I felt he was being loyal to someone. Either to Maxim
or to Rebecca, or perhaps even to himself I did not know what to
make of it.
‘She must have been drowned, then, trying to swim to shore?’
I imagined how the little boat would rock from side to side, and
how the water would suddenly rush in and the sails push her
down. It must have been very dark out there in the bay.The shore
must have seemed very far away to anyone swimming there, in the
‘How long afterwards did they find her?’
‘About two months.’
Two months? I thought drowned people were found after about
two days. I thought they would be washed up when the tide came
‘Where did they find her?’
‘Near Edgecoombe — about sixty kilometres up the coast.’
‘How did they know it was her — after two months, how could
they teU?’ I wondered why he paused before each sentence, as
though carefully considering his words. Had he cared for her, then;
had he minded so much?
‘Maxim went up to Edgecoombe to see the body. He recognized
Suddenly I did not want to ask him any more. I felt sick. I hated
myself And there was an awkwardness between us that could not
be ignored. ^
‘Frank,’ I said hopelessly, ‘I know what you’re thinking. You can’t
understand why 1 asked all those questions just now. You think that
I’m interested in a — in a rather unpleasant way. It’s not that. It’s
only that – that sometimes I feel myself at such a disadvantage. It’s
all strange to me, living here at Manderley. It’s not the sort of life
I’m used to. I know people are looking me up and down, wondering
what I will make of it. I can imagine them . saying ‘What on earth
does Maxim see in her?’And then, Frank,
I begin to wonder myself, and I have a fearful feeling that I should
never have married Maxim, that we are not going to be happy. I
know that they are all thinking the sswne thing — “How different
she is from Rebecca’’.’
1 stopped, breathless, and already a litde ashamed of myself.
Frank turned to me, looking very troubled. ‘Mrs de Winter,
please don’t think that,’ he said.‘I cannot tell you how glad I am
that you have married Maxim. It will make all the difference to his
life. I know you will make a great success of it. And if people
round here make you feel that they are finding fault, it’s – well – it’s
most terribly rude of them. I have never heard a word of it,
‘Thank you, Frank. What you say helps a lot. I expect I have
been very stupid. I’m not good at meeting new people. I’ve never
had to do it. And all the time I keep remembering how – how it
must have been at Manderley before, when there was somebody
here who was born to it, and did it all naturally and without effort.
And I realize every day that she possessed the things I lack –
confidence, beauty, brains – all the qualities that mean most in a
woman. It doesn’t help, Frank.’
He said nothing, but he went on looking anxious. ‘You must not
say that,’ he said.
‘Why not? It’s true.’
‘You have qualities that are just as important. Far more so, in
fact. I don’t know you very well. I’m not married, and I don’t know
much about women, but I would say that kindness, and honesty
and – if I may say so — modesty, are worth far more to a husband
than all the brains and beauty in the world.’
He looked worried still. ‘I’m sure that Maxim would be very
disturbed if he knew how you felt. I don’t think he can have any
idea of it. You are fresh and young and sensible; you have nothing
to do with all that time that has gone. Forget it, Mrs de Winter, as
he has done, thank heaven, and the rest of us. We none of us want
to bring back the past. Maxim least of all. And it’s for you, you
know, to lead us away from it. Not to take us back there again.’
He was right, of course. Dear, good Frank.‘I ought to have told
you this before. I feel happier — much happier. And I have you for
my friend, whatever happens, haven’t I, Frank?’
‘Yes, of course.’
‘Frank, before we put an end to this conversation, for ever, will
you answer just one question?’
‘Very well. I will do my best.’
‘Tell me,’ I said lightly, as though I did not care a bit, ‘tell me,
was Rebecca very beautiful?’
Frank waited a moment. I could not see his face; he was looking
away from me, towards the house.‘Yes,’ he said slowly,‘yes — 1
suppose she was the most beautiful creature I ever saw in my life.’
We went up the steps, into the hall, and I rang the bell for tea.
Chapter 5 Rebecca’s Room
Maxim had to go up to London at the end of June to some public
dinner. He was away for two days, and I was left alone. After lunch,
I called Jasper, and we set off towards the shore. Jasper led the way,
and went straight to the bay where the harbour was. The door of
the cottage was not quite closed. I pushed it open and looked inside.
Nothing had changed. Then 1 heard a noise in the boat store.
‘Is anybody there?’ No answer. 1 looked round the edge of the
door. Someone was trying to hide behind one of the sails. It was
‘What’s the matter? Do you want something?’
He looked at me stupidly, his mouth open.
Tm not doing nothing;’ he saidi
‘I think you’d better come out,’ 1 said.‘Mr de Winter doesn’t like
people walking in and out of here.’
He got up, one hand behind his back.
‘What have you got, Ben?’ 1 asked. He obeyed like a child,
showing me his hand.There was a fishing line in it.Tm not doing
nothing,’ he said again.‘I done nothing. I don’t want to be put in the
madhouse.’ A tear rolled down his dirty face. ‘You’re not like the
other one, though.’
‘Who do you mean? What ocher one?’
‘Tall and dark she was. She gave you the feeling of a snake. I’ve
seen her here with my own eyes. By night, she’d come. I’ve seen
her.’ He paused, watching me closely. 1 did not say anything. ‘I
looked in on her once, and she shouted at me, she did. “You don’t
know me, do you?” she said.“You’ve never seen me here, and you
won’t again. If I catch you looking through the windows here I’ll
have you put in the madhouse.You wouldn’t like that, would you?
They’re cruel to people in the madhouse.” “I won’t say nothing,
madam,” I said, and I touched my cap, like this. She’s gone now,
hasn’t she?’ he added anxiously.
‘I don’t know who you mean,’ I said slowly;‘no one is going to
put you in the madhouse. Good afternoon, Ben.’
I walked up the path. Poor thing — he was mad, of course. He
didn’t know what he was talking about. It was hardly likely that
anyone would threaten him with the mental hospiiisl. Maxim had
said he was quite harmless, and so had Frank. Suddenly I wanted to
run. I had been a fool to come to this bay. I should have gone to the
other bay, by Happy Valley.
When I got back to the house there was no one about. It was’ too
early for tea. But I had not been long in the sitting room when I
heard a footstep, and a man came into the room. He did not see me
at first, but when he did he looked quite surprised. I might have
been the thief, and he the master of the house. He was a big, strong
man, good-looking in a rather self-conscious, sunburnt way. He
had the hot blue eyes of a heavy drinker. In a few years’ time he
would certainly be fat. His mouth was soft and pink, and he smelt
of drink. He began to smile – the sort of smile he would give to
‘I hope I didn’t frighten you,’ he said.
‘No – of course not. I – I didn’t expect visitors this afternoon.’
‘What a shame — it’s coo bad of me to come in like this. The fact
is, I came to see Mrs Danvers. She’s an old friend of mine.’
‘Oh, of course — it s quite all right.’
‘How’s old Max?’
1 was surprised at his question. It sounded as though he knew
him well. But it was strange to hear Maxim spoken of as Max. No
one called him that.
‘He’s very well, thank you. He’s gone up to London.’
‘And left you all alone? That’s too bad. Isn’t he afraid someone
will come and carry you otf?’
He laughed. 1 did not like his laugh. I did not like him, either.
Just then Mrs Danvers came into the room. She turned her eyes
towards me, and I felt quite cold. How she seemed to hate me!
‘Hullo, Danny. There you are! Aren’t you going to introduce
‘This is Mr Favell, madam.’ She spoke quiedy, as if she would
have preferred to say nothing at aU.
‘How do you do?’ I said.
‘Well, I suppose I’d better be going. Come out and have a look at
my car.’ He still spoke in a familiar and unpleasant way. I did not
want to go and look at his Car. I felt awkward, but could not think
of an excuse.
‘Where is it?’
‘Round the corner; I didn’t drive to the door – I was afraid of
disturbing you. I had some idea you probably rested in the
I said nothing. The lie was too obvious. We walked out to his car,
a green sports thing, typical of its owner.
‘Come for a drive down to the gates?’
‘No, I don’t think I will. I’m rather tired.’
‘You don’t think it would look too good for the wife of the
master of Manderley to be seen driving with someone like me, is
that it?’ he laughed.
‘Oh, no,’ I said, turning rather red. ‘No, really’
‘Oh, well – goodbye. By the way, it would be very sporting of
you not to say anything to Max about my little visit. He doesn’t
quite approve of me, I’m afraid, and it might get poor old Danny
‘No,’ I said awkwardly, ‘all right.’
‘Very sporting of you. Sure you won’t change your mind and
come for a drive? No? Goodbye, then.’ The car shot down the drive.
I walked slowly back to the house. Maxim was away; I was
supposed to be out on a long walk. It was Frith’s day out, and the
other servants were usually upstairs changing the beds during the
afternoon. Favell had chosen his time well to call on Mrs
Danvers.Too well.Who was he? As I stood in the hall the thought
suddenly came to me that perhaps Mrs Danvers was dishonest, that
she was dcftng something behind Maxim’s back. Supposing this
man Favell was a thief, and Mrs Danvers was in his pay? There
were valuable things in the west wing. I suddenly decided to go
upstairs and see for myself. My heart was beating in a strange,
Upstairs, there was no sound at all. I was uncertain which way
to go. The plan of the rooms was not familiar to me. But I turned
the handle of a door and went inside. It was dark; the curtains were
closed. I turned the light on, and with a shock of surprise saw that
the room was full of furniture, not covered in dustsheets as I had
expected, but just as though it were in use. There were brushes and
combs on the dressing table. The bed was made up. There were
flowers. Shoes were neatly positioned in front of a chair. For one
strange moment I thought that something had happened to my
brain, that I was seeing back in time and looking at the rbom as it
used to be, before she died … In a minute, Rebecca herself would
come back into the room, sit down at her dressing table, reach for
her comb and start running it through her hair. I went on standing
there, waiting for something to happen. It was the sound of the
clock that brought me back to
reality again. The hands stood at twenty-five past four. My watch said
the same. It reminded me that tea would soon be ready under the trees.
No – this room was not used. It was not lived in any more. Even if Mrs
Danvers did put the flowen on the tables and the sheets on the bed, they
would not bring Rebecca back. She was dead. She had been dead for a
year now. She lay buried below the church, with all the other dead de
But yes, it was a beautiful room. Mrs Danvers had told the truth that
first evening. It was the most beautiful room in the house. I touched
the sheets; on the bed was a nightdress, cold now, but still carrying a
woman’s faint and lovely smell. I looked round with a growing feeling
of disgust, disgust turning to hopelessness.
Then I heard a step behind me and, turning round, I saw .Mrs
Danvers. I shall never forget the look on her face – evil, excited in a
strange, unhealthy way. I felt very frightened.
‘Is anything the matter, madam?’ she said.
I tried to smile and could not. I tridid to speak.
‘Are you feeling unwell?’ she asked, coming near to me, speaking
very softly. I felt her breath on my face.
Tm all right, Mrs Danvers,’ I said, after a moment. ‘I didn’t expect
to see you.’
‘You wanted to see the room? Why have you never asked me to
show it to you before? You only had to ask me.’
I wanted to run away, but I could not move. I went on watching her
‘Now you are here, let me show you everything,’ she said, her voice
sweet and false. ‘I know you want to see it all – you’ve wanted to for a
long time, but didn’t like to ask. It’s a lovely room, isn’t it? The
loveliest room you have ever seen. This is her bed; here is her
nightdress. You have been touching it, haven’t you? Feel – how soft
and light it is! This is the nightdress she was wearing the night before
she died. She was wearing trousers, of
course, and a shirt when she was drowned. They were torn from
her body in the water, though. There was nothing on the hody
when it was found, all those weeks afterwards.’ Her fingers
tightened on my arm, her face was close, her dark eyes searching
mine. ‘The rocks had knocked her to pieces, you know; her
beautiful face was unrecognizable, and both arms gone. Mr de
Winter went up to Edgecoombe. He went quite alone. He was very
ill at the time, but he was determined to go. No one could stop him
– not even Mr Crawley’ She paused, her eyes never leaving my
face.‘I shall always blame myself for the accident,’ she said. ‘It was
my fault for being out that evening. I had gone into Kerrith for the
afternoon and stayed there late, as Mrs de Winter was up in London
and wasn’t expected back until much later. That’s why I didn’t
hurry back. When 1 came in, about half past nine, I heard she had
returned, then had dinner and gone out again. Down to the boat, of
course. 1 felt worried then. The wind was blowing from the
south-west. She would never have gone if 1 had been in. She always
listened to me.’ Her fingers held me tightly, hurting my arm. ‘Mr de
Winter had been dining with Mr Crawley down at his house,’ she
went on. ‘1 don’t know what time he got back. 1 expect it was after
eleven. But it began to blow hard before midnight, and she had not
come back. 1 went and knocked on the bedroom door. Mr de
Winter answered immediately. “Who is it? What do you want?” In
a moment he opened the door, wearing his night clothes.“She’s
spending the night down at the cottage, 1 expect,” he said;“l should
go to bed if 1 were you. She won’t come back here to sleep if the
storni goes on like this.” He looked tired, and 1 did not want to
disturb him again. After all, she spent many nights at the cottage,
and was used to saihng in any weather. She might not even have
gone for a sail, but just wanted a night at the cottage, as a change
after London. I said good night to Mr de Winter and went back to
my room. I couldn’t sleep, though. I kept wondering what she was
She paused again. I did not want to hear any more. I wanted to
get away from her, away from the room.
‘You know now why Mr de Winter doesn’t use these rooms any
more. Listen to the sea! He hasn’t used these rooms since the night
she was drowned. Sometimes when Mr de Winter is away and you
feel lonelyfyou might like to come up to these rooms and sit here.
You only have to tell me.’ Her smile was a false, unnatural thing.
‘They are such beautiful rooms. You wouldn’t think she had been
gone so long, would you, by the way the rooms are kept? You would
think she had just gone out for a little while and would be back in
the evening. It’s not only in this room – it’s in many rooms in the
house. In the sitting room, the hall, the little flower room. I feel her
everywhere. You do, too, don’t you?’ She paused, watching my
eyes. ‘Do you think she. can see us, talking to one another now? Do
you think the dead come back and watch the living?’
I swallowed. ‘I don’t know’ My voice sounded high, unnatural.
Not my voice at all.
‘Sometimes I wonder,’ she whispered. ‘Sometimes I wonder if
she comes back to Manderley and watches you and Mr de Winter
We stood there, watching one another. I could not take my eyes
away from hers. How dark they were, how full of hatred! Then she
opened the door and stepped to one side for me to pass. ‘Tea is ready
now,’ she said. ‘They have orders to take it out under the trees.’
Next day, in Beatrice’s car, I wondered whether to tell her about
Mrs Danvers. About the man Favell.
‘Beatrice,’ I said, deciding that I would, ‘have you ever heard of
someone called FaveU? Jack Favell?’
‘Jack Favell,’ she repeated. ‘Yes, I do know the name. Wait a.
minute. Jack Favell? Yes, of course. A terrible man! 1 met him once,
‘He came to Manderley yesterday, to see Mrs Danvers,’ 1 said.
‘Really? Oh, well – perhaps he would …’
‘I believe he was Rebecca’s cousin.’
I was very surprised.That man her relation? It was not my idea
of the sort of cousin Rebecca would have. Jack Favell her cousin.
‘Oh,’ I said.‘I hadn’t realized that.’
‘He probably used to go to Manderley a lot. I don’t know. I
couldn’t tell you. I was very rarely there.’ 1 felt she didn’t want to
talk about him.
‘I didn’t like him much,’ I said.
‘No,’ said Beatrice.‘I don’t blame you.’
I waited, but she did not say any more.
When 1 got back to Manderley, Maxim’s hat was lying on the
table. As I went towards the library, 1 heard the sound of voices,
one raised louder than the other – Maxim’s voice. The door was
shut, and I paused.
‘You can write and tell him from me to keep away from
Manderley in future, do you hear? Never mind who told me; I
happen to know that his car was seen here yesterday afternoon. If
you want to meet him, you can meet him outside Manderley. I
won’t have him inside the gates, do you understand? Remember –
I’m warning you – for the last time!’
I moved quickly away. Mrs Danvers came out of the library. She
did not see me, but for a moment I saw her face, grey with anger,
1 waited a moment, then I went in. Maxim was standing by the
window, holding some letters in his hand, his back turned to me.
‘Who is it now?’ he said.
I smiled, holding out my hands. ‘Hullo!’ I said.
‘Oh, it’s you …’
I could see that something had made him very angry. His mouth
was hard, his face white. We sat down together by the window.
‘Was it hot up in London?’
‘Yes, quite bad. I always hate the place.’
I wondered if he would tell me what had happened just now
with Mrs Danvers. 1 wondered who had told him about Favell.
‘Are you worried about something?’
‘I’ve had a long day. That drive twice in twenty-four hours is too
much for anyone.’ He got up and wandered away, lighting his pipe.
I knew then that he was not going to tell me about Mrs Danvers.
Chapter 6 The Fancy-Dress Dance
It was one Sunday, I remember, when we had visitors, that the
subject of the fancy-dress dance was first brought up. Maxim’s eyes
met mine over the teapot.
‘What do you think?’ he said.
‘I don’t know,’ I said uncertainly. ‘I don’t mind.’
‘I think everyone would enjoy a show of some sort,’ said Frank.
Maxim still looked at me doubtfully over the teapot. Perhaps he
thought I could not manage it. I did not want him to think that. I
did not want him to think I would let him down.
‘I think it would be rather fun,’ I said.
‘That setdes it, of course. All right, Frank. Go ahead with the
arrangements. Better get Mrs Danvers to help you. She’ll remember
how we used to do things.’
‘I’ve got the records in the office. It won’t really mean much
work. Mrs de Winter needn’t worry about anything.’ I wondered
what they would do if I suddenly said that I would take charge
of the whole affair. Laugh, I suppose, and then begin talking of
‘What on earth shall I wear?’ 1 said. ‘I’m not much good at fancy
dress. I tell you what. I’ll keep my choice a surprise until the last
minute.Then I’ll give you and Frank the surprise of your lives.’
The preparations went on for the dance. Maxim and Frank were
busy every morning and I began to worry about what I was going to
wear. It seemed so silly not to be able to think of anything. One
evening, when I was changing for dinner, there was a knock at my
bedroom door. I called ‘Come in,’ thinking it was my servant,
Clarice. It was Mrs Danvers.
‘I hope you will forgive me disturbing you,’ she said.‘Have you
decided yet, madam, what you will wear?’
There was a suggestion of scorn in her voice, of strange
satisfaction. She must have heard through Clarice that I still had no
‘No. I haven’t decided.’
‘Why don’t you copy the clothes from one of the pictures in the
‘Yes. I might think about that.’ I wondered why such an idea had
not come to me before. It was an obvious solution to my problem.
‘All the pictures in the hall would be easy to copy, especially
that one of the young lady in white, with her hat in her hand.’ Her
voice was surprisingly normal. Did she want to be friends with me
at last? Or did she realize that it was not I who had told Maxim
about Favell, and was this her way of thanking me for my silence?
‘Has Mr de Winter not suggested anything for you?’
‘No. No, I want to surprise him and Mr Crawley’
‘When you do decide, I would advise you to have your dress
made in London. Voce, in Bond Street, is a good place I know. I
should study фе pictures in the hall, madam, especially the one I
mentioned. And you needn’t think that I’ll give you away. I won’t
say a word to anyone.’
‘Thank you, Mrs Danvers.’ I went on dressing, confused by her
manner, and wondering if I had the unpleasant Favell to thank for
When I looked at the picture, I saw that the clothes in it were
lovely, and would be easy to copy. It was a painting by Raeburn of
Caroline de Winter, who had been a famous London beauty in the
eighteenth century. She wore a simple white dress. The hat might
be rather difficult, but I could carry it in my hand, as she did. I
would have to wear a hairpiece. My hair would never curl in that
way. Perhaps Voce in London would do the whole thing. It was a
relief to have decided at last.
Clarice could hardly contain herself for excitement, and I began to
feel the same as the great day came near. Beatrice and her husband
were coming to stay the night, and a lot of other people were
coming to dinner before the dance began.
I found Clarice waiting for me in my room, her round face red
with excitement. We laughed at each other like schoolgirls. The
dress fitted perfectly.
‘It’s lovely, madam – fit for the Queen of England!’
‘Give me the curls carefully. Don’t spoil them.’With trembling
fingers I made the finishing touches. ‘Oh, Clarice, what will Mr de
Winter say?’ I did not recognize the face that I saw in the mirror.
The eyes were larger, surely, thfe mouth thinner, the skin white
and clear? The curls stood away from the head in a litde cloud. I
watched this self that was not me at aU, and then smiled; a new,
‘They’ve gone down,’ said Clarice. ‘They’re aU standing in the
hall. Mr de Winter, Captain and Mrs Lacy, and Mr Crawley.’ I
went along the passage and looked down, hidden from view at the
top of the stairs.
‘1 don’t know what she’s doing,’ Maxim was saying,‘she’s been
up in the bedroom for hours.’
The band were near me, getting their instruments ready.
‘Make the drummer give a roll on the drum,’ 1 whispered, ‘and
then shout out ‘Miss Caroline de Winter’.’ What fun it was!
Suddenly the sound of the drum filled the great hall; I saw them
look up, surprised.
‘Miss Caroline de Winter!’ shouted the drummer.
I came forward to the top of the stairs and stood there, smihng,
my hat in my hand like the girl in the picture. I waited for the
laughter and shouts of approval that would follow as I walked
slowly down the stairs. Nobody moved. They all stared at me,
speechless. Beatrice gave a little cry and put her hand to her mouth.
I went on smiling.
‘How do you do, Mr de Winter?’ I said.
Maxim had not moved. He looked up at me, his glass in his hand.
All the colour left his face. I stopped, one foot on the next stair.
Something was wrong. They had not understood. Why was Maxim
looking like that? Why did they all stand as if they were made of
Then Maxim moved forward, his eyes never leaving my face.
‘What the devil do you think you are doing?’ His eyes flashed
with anger. His face was ash grey. 1 could not move.
‘It’s the picture,’ I said.‘It’s the picture – the one in the hall.’
There was a long silence. We went on looking at each other.
Nobody moved in the hall. 1 swallowed; my hand moved to my
throat. ‘What is it?’ I said. ‘What have I done?’
If only they wouldn’t look at me like that with dull,
expressionless faces. If only somebody would say something. When
Maxim spoke again, I did not recognize his voice. It was quiet, cold
as ice – not a voice I knew.
‘Go and change,’ he said. ‘It doesn’t matter what you put on. Find
an ordinary evening dress – anything will do. Go now, before
anybody else comes.’
1 could not speak. 1 went on looking at him. His eyes were the
only living things in his dead, grey face.
‘What are you standing there for?’ His voice was ugly and
strange. ‘Didn’t you hear what I said?’
I turned and ran blindly down the passage behind me. Clarice
had gone. Tears filled my eyes. Then I saw Mrs Danvers. I shall
never forget the expression on her face – the face of a victorious
devil. She stood there, smiling at me. And then I ran fiom her,
down the long passage to my own room.
Somebody knocked.The door opened and Beatrice came in.
‘My dear! Are you all right? You look very white. Of course I
knew immediately it was just a terrible mistake. You couldn’t
possibly have known. Why should you?’
‘Why the dress, you poor dear – the picture you copied of the girl
in the hall. It was what Rebecca did at the last fancy-dress dance at
Manderley. Exactly the same. The same picture, the same dress.
You stood there on the stairs, and for one terrible moment I
thought .. .You poor child, how were you to know?’
‘I ought to have known,’ I said stupidly. ‘I ought to have known.’
‘Nonsense – bow could you? It was not the sort of thing that
could possibly enter any of our heads. Only it was such a shock, you
see. We none of iis expected it, and Maxim …’
‘He thinks, you see, you did it on purpose. You had said you
would surprise him, hadn’t you? Some foolish joke. And, of course,
he doesn’t understand. It was such a shock for him. I told
him that you couldn’t have done such a thing on purpose, and that
it was just bad luck that you chose that particular picture.’
‘I ought to have known. It’s all my fault. I ought to have known!’
‘No, no. Don’t worry.You’ll be able to explain the whole thing
to him quietly. Everything will be aU right. The first lot of people
are just arriving. I’ve told Frank to make up a story of your dress
not fitting, and how disappointed you are.’
I did not say anything. I went on sitting on the bed. I kept seeing
Maxim’s eyes in his grey face, and the others behind him, not
moving, just staring at me.
Chapter 7 The Sunken Boat
It seemed to me the next morning, as I lay in bed, staring at the
wall, at the faint light coming in at the window, at Maxim’s empty
bed, that there was nothing quite so shaming as a marriage that had
failed. Failed after three months, as mine had done. For I no longer
made any effort to pretend. Last night h^d shown me too well. My
marriage was hopeless. We were not companions. I was too young
for Maxim, too inexperienced, and more important still, I was not
of his world. Even Mrs Van Hopper had known it. ‘I’m afraid you’ll
be sorry. I believe you’re making a big mistake.’ I would not listen
to her; I thought she was hard and cruel. But she was right. ‘Don’t
imagine that he’s in love with you! He’s lonely. He can’t bear that
great empty house, that’s all.’ It was true! Maxim was not in love
with me; he had never loved me. He did not belong to me at all, he
belonged to Rebecca. She was in the house stiU, as Mrs Danvers
had said, and he would never love me, because of her.
Outside, low clouds of mist hung around the windows. Thick
and white, they smelt of the salty sea. I could see nothing out of
the windows; everything was hidden in mist and silence.
Suddenly an explosion shook the windows. It was followed by
another, and another. The birds rose unseen from the woods and
filled the air with their noise. I heard the sound of footsteps
running below. It was Maxim. I could*’ not see him, but I could
hear his voice.
‘There’s a ship in trouble,’ he was saying. ‘She’s signalling for
help. She must have mistaken our bay for Kerrith harbour. The
mist is as thick as anything out there. If she’s on the rocks, they’ll
never move her. I’m going down to see if I can do anything.’
It was getting warmer. A pale sun was trying to shine, and the
heavy mist was lifting. When I reached the shore the mist had
almost gone, and I could see the ship, lying about three kilometres
out, with some small rowing boats already around her. In a dark
grey motorboat was the harbour master from Kerrith. Another
motorboat followed, full of holidaymakers. 1 climbed up the path
over the cliff. I did not see Maxim there, but Frank was talking to
one of the coastguards, a man I had met before.
‘Come to see the fun, Mrs de Winter? I’m afraid it will be a
difficult business. They may move her, but I doubt it. She’s stuck on
‘What will they do?’
‘They’ll send a diver down now to see if she’s broken her back.’
A small boy came riihning up to us. ‘Will the sailors be drowned?’
‘Not them! They’re all right, son,’ said the coastguard.‘The sea’s
as flat as the back of my hand. No one’s going to be hurt this time.
There’s the diver, Mrs de Winter! See him?’
‘I want to see the diver,’ said the small boy.
‘There he is,’ said Frank, bending down and pointing. ‘They’re
going to lower him into the water.’
‘Won’t he be drowned?’
‘Divers don’t drown. They have air pumped down to them all
the time. Watch him disappear.There he goes!’
‘He’s gone,’ said the small boy.
‘Where’s Maxim?’ I asked.
‘He’s taken one of the sailors into Kerrith, to the doctor. I don’t
suppose anything will happen now for hours.The diver will have to
make his report before they try to move her. I want my lunch.
Why not come back and have some with me?’
‘I think I’ll stay here a bit. I want to see what the diver’s going to
do.’ Somehow 1 could not face Frank at the moment. I wanted to be
It was after three o’clock when I looked at my watch. 1 got up and
went down the hill to the bay. It was quiet and deserted as always.
When I came to the further side of the bay I saw Ben sitting by a
‘Good day,’ he said, his wet mouth opening in a smile.
‘Good afternoon,’ I replied.
He stood up. ‘Seen the ship?’
‘Yes. She’s in trouble, isn’t she?’
‘She’s on the rocks. I expect she’s got a hole in her.’
His face looked empty and foolish. ‘Yes,’ he said. ‘She’s down
there all right. She’ll not come back again.’
‘Perhaps they’ll get her off when the tide comes in.’
He did not answer. He was staring out towards the ship. ‘She’ll
break up, where she is.’
‘I’m afraid so.’
He smiled again, and wiped his nose with the back of his hand.
‘She’ll break up bit by bit. She’ll not sink like a stone, like the little
one.’ He laughed quietly to himself I did not say anything. ‘The
fishes have eaten her up by now, haven’t they?’
‘Who?’ 1 said.
‘Her. The other one.’
‘Fishes don’t eat boats, Ben,’ I said.
‘Eh?’ he said. He stared at me, foolish and dull once more.
‘1 must go home now,’ 1 said. ‘Good afternoon.’
1 left him, and walked up the path through the woods to the
Just as 1 was having tea, Robert came in.
‘Mr de Winter isn’t back yet, is he, madam?’
‘No,’ I said. ‘Does someone want him?’
‘Yes, madam. It’s Captain Searle, the harbour master from
Kerrith. He says the matter is rather urgent. He tried to get Mr
Crawley, but there was no reply.’
‘Well, of course I must see him, if it’s important.’
I wondered what I would say to Captain Searle. It must be
something to do with the ship. I could not understand what
concern it was of Maxim’s.
I got up and shook hands with him when he came in. ‘I’m sorry
my husband isn’t back yet. Captain Searle. I’m afraid the ship has
disorganized everybody. Will they get her off, do you think?’
Captain Searle made a great circle with his hands. ‘There’s a hole
that big in her,’ he said. ‘She’ll not see home again. But never mind
the ship – her owner and the insurance company will setde that
between them. No, Mrs de Winter, it’s not the ship that’s brought
me here.The fact is, I have some news for Mr de Winter, and I
hardly know how to tell it to him.’ He looked at me very straight
with his bright blue eyes.
‘What sort of news. Captain Searle?’
He brought a large white handkercilief out of his pocket and
blew his nose. ‘Well, Mrs de Winter, it’s not very pleasant for me to
tell you, either. The last thing I want to do is to cause pain to you or
your husband. We’re all very fond of Mr de Winter in Kerrith, you
know, and the family has always done a lot of good.
It’s hard on him and it’s hard on you that we can’t let the past lit
quiet. But I don’t see how we can.’ He paused, and put his
handkerchief back in his pocket. He lowered his voice, although
we were alone in the room.
‘We sent the diver down to examine the ship’s bottom; he found
the hole, and was working his way round to see what other damage
there was, when he came across a little sailing boat, lying on her
side, quite whole and not broken up at all. He’s a local man, of
course, and he recognized the boat immediately. It was the little
boat belonging to the first Mrs de Winter.’
‘I’m so sorry,’ I said slowly, ‘it’s not the sort of thing one
expected would happen. Is it necessary to tell Mr de Winter?
Couldn’t the boat be left there as it is? It’s not doing any harm, is it?’
‘It would be left, Mrs de Winter, in the ordinary way. I’d give
anything, as I said before, to spare Mr de Winter’s feehngs. But that
wasn’t all, Mrs de Winter. He found the door tightly closed, and
the windows, too. But he broke one of the windows with a piece of
rock, and looked inside. It was full of water; it must have come in
through some hole in the bottom. There seemed to be no damage
elsewhere. And then he got the fright of his life, Mrs de Winter.’
Captain Searle paused; he looked over his shoulder as though
one of the servants might hear him. ‘There was a body in there,
lying on the floor. There was no flesh left on it, but it was a body all
right . . . And now you understand, Mrs de Winter, why I’ve got to
see your husband.’
I kept looking at him, confused at first, then shocked, then
‘She was supposed to be sailing alone,’ I whispered,‘there must
have been someone with her all the time then, and no one ever
‘It looks like it.’
‘Who could it have been? Surely relatives would know if anyone
was missing? There was so much in the papers about it. Why should
one of them be still in the boat and Mrs de Winter be found many
kilometres away, and months afterwards?’
Captain Searle shook his head.‘I can’t tell. All we know is that
the body is there, and it has got to be reported. It’s very hard on you
and Mr de Winter. Here you are, settled down quietly, wanting to
be happy, and now this has to happen. But I’ve got to do my duty.
I’ve got to report that body.’ He stopped as the door opened and
Maxim came into the room.
‘Hullo – what’s happening? I didn’t know you were here. Captain
Searle. Is anything the matter?’
I could not stand it any longer. I went out of the room, like the
coward I was, and shut the door behind me.
When I heard the sound of a car starting up the drive, I went
slowly back to the library. Maxim was standing by the window. He
did not turn round. I reached for his hand.
‘I’m so sorry — so terribly, terribly sorry.’
His hand was icy cold. He did not answer.
‘I don’t want you to bear this alone,’ I said.‘I want to share it
with you. I’ve grown up, Maxim, in twenty-four hours.’
He put his arm round me and pulled me close.
‘You’ve forgiven me, haven’t you?’
He spoke to me at last. ‘Forgiven you?’ he said. ‘What have I got
to forgive you for?’
‘Last night,’ I said. ‘You thought I did it on purpose.’
‘Ah, that,’ he said. ‘I’d forgotten. I was angry with you, wasn’t I?’
He did not say any more. He went on holding me.
‘Maxim,’ I said, ‘can’t we start aU over again? Can’t we begin
from today, and face things together?’
He took my face between his hands and looked at me. For the ‘ ’’t
time I saw how thin his face was, how lined and tired. There ’at
shadows beneath his eyes.
‘It’s too late, my love, too late. We’ve lost our little chance of
‘No, Maxim, no,’ I said.
‘Yes. It’s all over now. The thing has happened.’
‘The thing I have always expected. The thing I have dreamed
about, night after night. We were not meant for happiness, you and
‘What are you trying to tell me?’
He put his hands over mine and looked into my face.‘Rebecca
has won,’ he said.
I stared at him, my heart beating strangely, my hands suddenly
cold beneath his hands.
‘Her shadow was between us all the time — her shadow keeping
us from one another. I remember her eyes as she looked at me
before she died. I remember that last slow smile. She knew this
would happen even then. She knew she would win in the end.’
‘Maxim,’ I whispered, ‘what are you saying? What are you trying
to tell me?’
‘Her boat,’ he said.‘They’ve found it – the diver found it this
‘Yes, I know,’ I said. ‘Captain Searle came to tell me. You’re
thinking about the body, aren’t you — the body the diver found in
‘It means she was not alone. It means there was somebody
sailing with Rebecca at the time. And you have to find out who it
was. That’s it, isn’t it, Maxim?’
‘No,’ he said. ‘No.You don’t understand.’
‘I want to share this with you, Maxim. I want to help you!’
‘There was no one with Rebecca. She was alone.’
I did not move. I watched his face.
‘It’s Rebecca’s body lying there in the boat,’ he said.
‘No,’ I said. ‘No.’
‘The woman buried below the church is not Rebecca. It’s the
body of some unknown woman, unclaimed, belonging nowhere.
There never was an accident. Rebecca was not drowned at all. I
killed her. I shot Rebecca in the cottage in the bay. I carried her
body to the boat, and sailed it out that night and sank it there,
where they found it today. It’s Rebecca who’s lying dead there on
the floor in the bpat.Will you look into my eyes and tell me that
you love me now?’
It was very quiet in the library.When people suffer a great shock,
like death, or the loss of an arm or a leg, I believe they do not feel it
at first. If your hand has gone, you don’t know for a few
minutes.You go on feeling the fingers.You stretch them and move
them one by one and all the time there is nothing there – no hand,
no fingers. I, too, felt no pain, no fear, there was no horror in my
heart. Little by little, feeling will come back to me, I thought; little
by little I shall understand. What he has told me wiU fall into place
and I will understand. They will fit themselves into a pattern. At
the moment I am nothing. 1 have no heart, no mind, no senses. I am
just a wooden thing in Maxim’s arms.
‘What will they do?’ I said, stupidly.
‘They will know it’s her body. Everything is there – the shoes,
the rings on her fingers. Then they vdll remember the other one —
the woman buried below the church.’
‘What are you going to do?’ I whispered.
‘I don’t know,’ he said. ‘I don’t know’
The feeling was coming back to me, little by little, as I knew it
would. My hands were no longer cold. I felt a wave of colour come
into my face. Maxim had killed Rebecca. Rebecca had not been
drowned at all. Maxim had killed her. He had,carried her
body со the boat, and sunk the boat there in the bay. I began to
understand . . . Maxim’s silence. The way he never talked about
Rebecca. His dislike of the little bay, of the stone cottage.‘If you had
my memories you would not go there either.’ The way he went so
quickly up the path through the woods, not looking behind him. ‘I
came away in rather a hurry,’ he said to Mrs Van Hopper, with that
look on his face.‘They say he can’t get over his wife’s death.’ The
fancy-dress dance last night, and I coming to the head of the stairs,
in Rebecca’s dress. ‘I killed Rebecca,’ Maxim had said. ‘I shot
Rebecca in the cottage.’ And the diver had found her lying there, on
the floor of the boat.
‘What are we going to do?’ I said. ‘What are we going to say?’ Maxim
did not answer. He stood there by the fireplace, his eyes wide and
staring, looking in front of him, not seeing anything. ‘Does anyone
know? Anyone at all?’
He shook his head. ‘No.’
‘No one but you and me?’ I thought for a moment. ‘Frank!’ I said
suddenly. ‘Are you sure Frank doesn’t know?’
‘How could he? There was nobody there but myself It was dark .
. .’ He stopped. He sat down in a chair, he put his hand up to his
forehead. I went and knelt beside him. He sat very still. I took his
hand from his face and looked into his eyes. ‘I love you,’ I
whispered.‘I love you.Will you believe me now?’ He kissed me, and
held my hands very tightly, like a child needing comfort.
‘I thought I would go mad,’ he said, ‘sitting here, day after day,
waiting for something to happen. Eating and drinking, trying to
seem natural in front of Frith, the servants, Mrs Danvers — whom I
had not the courage to turn away, because with her knowledge of
Rebecca she might have guessed — Frank, always by my side, and
poor, dear Beatrice. I had to face them, all those people, knowing
that every word 1 said was a lie.’
‘Why didn’t you tell me? The time we’ve wasted when we might
have been together! All those weeks ..,’
‘You were so distant,’ he said, ‘always wandering into the garden
with Jasper, going off on your own. You never came to me like this.’
‘Why didn’t you tell me?’ I whispered. ‘Why didn’t you tell me?’
‘I thought you were unhappy, bored. I’m so much older than
you. You always had more to say to Frank than to me.You were
strange with me — awkward.’
‘How could I come to you, when I knew you were thinking of
Rebecca? How could I ask you to love me when I knew you still
He pulled me close to him and searched my eyes.
‘What are you talking about? What do you mean?’
‘Whenever you touched me I thought you were comparing me
with Rebecca. Whenever you spoke to me or looked at me, walked
with me in the garden, sat down to dinner, I felt that you were
saying to yourself, “This I did with Rebecca, and this, and this.”’ He
stared at me as if he did not understand.
‘It was true, wasn’t it?’ I said.
‘Oh, my God,’ he said. He pushed me away, and began walking
up and down the room.
‘What is it? What’s the matter?’
He turned suddenly and looked at me as I sat there on the floor.
‘You thought 1 loved Rebecca? You thought I killed her, loving her?
I hated her, I teU you. Our marriage was a lie from the very first.
She was a terrible woman; every bone in her body was bad. We
never loved each other; never had one moment of happiness
together. Rebecca had no love, no warmth. She was clever, of course
— very clever. No one would guess that she was not a kind,
generous and caring person. She knew exactly what to say to
everyone. If she had met you, she would have walked off into the
garden with you, arm-in-arm, talking about flowers, music,
painting, whatever she knew you were interested in, and
you would have been deceived like the rest.You would have loved
her. When I married her, I was told I was the luckiest man in the
world. She was so lovely, so intelligent, so amusing. But all the time
1 had a seed of doubt at the back of my mind. There was something
about her eyes .. .’
Bit by bit the real Rebecca took shape in front of me. Once more
I stood on the beach with poor Ben. ‘You’re not like the other one.
She gave you the feeling of a snake …’
Maxim was talking, though, walking up and down the library. ‘I
discovered her true nature immediately,’ he was saying,‘five days
after we were married. She told me about herself — told me things
1 shall never repeat to a living soul. I knew then what I had done,
what I had married. She made a deal with me. “I’ll run your house
for you,’’ she told me. “I’ll look after your dear old Manderley for
you – make it the most famous showplace in the country, if you like.
And people will visit us, and be jealous of us, and talk about us;
they’ll say we are the happiest, luckiest, bestlooking pair in
England. What a joke. Max!” she said, laughing. “What a great
joke!” She knew I would give up pride, honour, personal feelings,
everything, rather than stand before our little world after a week of
marriage and have them know the things about her that she had
told me then. I thought too much of Manderley. I put Manderley
first, before anything else. And it isn’t right, that sort of love. They
don’t speak about it in the churches. They don’t speak about stones,
and bricks, and walls, the love that a man can feel for his bit of
earth, his home and castle.’
‘Maxim, my love!’
‘Do you understand?’ he said. ‘Do you? Do you?’
‘Yes,’ I said. But I looked away from him so that he did not see
my face. What did it matter whether I understood? My heart was as
light as a feather. He had never loved Rebecca.
‘1 don’t want to look back on those years. The misery, the
disgust. The lie we lived, she and I. In front of friends, relations.
even the servants. They all believed in her down here, they all
admired her. They never knew how she laughed at them behind
their backs. I can remember days when the place was full for some
entertainment or other – a dance, or a garden party – and she walked
around with her arm through mine; then the next day she would be
up at daybreak driving to London, to that flat of hers by the river
like an animal to its hole in the ground, coming back here at the end
of the week, after five unspeakable days. Oh, I kept my part of the
deal all right. 1 never gave her away. And her good taste made
Manderley what it is today. The gardens, the sitting room, even the
flowers in the Happy Valley — the beauty of Manderley that people
talk about and photograph and paint, it’s all because of her, because
I did not say anything. I held him close. I wanted him to talk, so
that his bitterness would come out, carrying with it all the hatred
and disgust of those lost years.
‘And so we lived, month after month, year after year. I accepted
everything — because of Manderley. What she did in London did
not touch me – because it did not hurt Manderley. And she was
careful at first; there was never a whisper about her. Then she began
to ask her friends down here. She would have them at her cottage in
the bay. 1 told her she must keep to her part of the deal. She could
see her friends in London, but Manderley was mine. She smiled, but
said nothing. Then she started on Frank — poor pitiful Frank, who
had not understood, who had always thought we were the normal
happy pair we had’ pretended to be.
‘1 accused Rebecca, and we had a terrible, sickening scene. She
went up to London after that, and stayed there a month. I thought
she had learned her lesson. Then we had Beatrice and Giles for the
weekend, and 1 realized then what I had sometimes thought before,
that Beatrice did not like Rebecca. I believe she saw through her,
guessed that something was wrong. Giles went out sailing with
Rebecca, and when they came back I could see that
she had started on him, as she had done on Frank.’
All the pieces were fitting into place for me now – Frank’s
awkward manner when I spoke about Rebecca. Beatrice’s strange
attitude. The silence I had always taken for sympathy was a silence
of shame and embarrassment. It seemed unbelievable now that I
had never understood. I wondered how many people there were
who suffered because they could not break out from their own
self-consciousness and awkwardness. I had never had the courage
to demand the truth. If I had taken one step, Maxim would have
told me these things months ago.
‘Rebecca became careful again,’ he went on. ‘Her behaviour was
faultless. But if I happened to be away when she was here at
Manderley, I could never be certain what might happen. There had
been Frank, and Giles. She might get hold of one of our workmen,
someone from Kerrith, anyone . . . and then the blow would fall.
The talk, the shame I feared.
‘She had a cousin who had been abroad, but was living in
England again. He began coming here, if ever I was away. A man
called Jack FaveU.’
‘I know him; he came here the day you were in London.’ ‘You saw
him too? Why didn’t you tell me? I heard it from Frank, who saw his
car turn in at the gates.’
‘I thought it would remind you of Rebecca,’ I said.
‘Remind me?’ whispered Maxim. ‘As if I needed reminding.’ He
paused, and I wondered if he was thinking, as I was, of that flooded
boat beneath the waters in the bay.
‘She used to have this FaveU down to the cottage,’ said Maxim.
‘She would teU the servants she was going to sail and would not be
back before the morning. Then she would spend the night down
there with him- Once again I warned her. I said if I found him
here, anywhere in the grounds. I’d shoot him . . .The very thought
of him walking around the woods at Manderley, in places like the
Happy Valley, made me mad. I told her 1 would not stand
it.Then one day she went up to London and came back again the
same day, which she did not usually do. I did not expect her. I had
dinner that night with Frank at his house.
‘1 returned after dinner at about half past ten, and I saw her
things in the hall. 1 wondered what the devil she had come back
for. But she was not there. I guessed she had gone off again – down
to the bay. And 1 knew I could not stand this life of lies and deceit
any longer. 1 thought I’d take a gun and frighten him, frighten
them both. I went straight dov^n-to the cottage. The servants never
knew 1 had come back to the house at all. I slipped out into the
garden and through the woods. I saw a light in the cottage window,
and went straight in.^o my surprise_Rebecca was alone. She looked
‘I began immediately to talk to her about Favell. “This is the end,
do you understand? What you do in London does not concern me.
You can live with Favell there, or with anyone you like. But not
here. Not at Manderley.”
‘She said nothing for a moment. She looked at me, and then she
smiled. “Suppose it suits me better to live here? What then?” ‘“You
know the conditions,” I said. “I’ve kept my part of our miserable
deal, haven’t I? But you’ve cheated. You think you can treat my
house and my home like your own hole in London. I’ve had
enough, and my God, Rebecca, this is your last chance.’” ‘She
stretched herself, her arms above her head.
‘“You’re right. Max,” she said. “It’s time I changed.”’ She looked
very pale, very thin. She began walking up and down, her hands in
‘“Have you ever thought,” she said,“how hard it would be for you
to make a case against me? In a court of law, I mean. Do you realize
that you wouldn’t have a hope of proving anything? All your
friends — even the servants — believe our marriage to be a
‘“What about Frank? What about Beatrice?”’
‘She threw back her head and laughed. “What sort of a story do
you think Frank could tell, against mine? As for Beatrice —
wouldn’t it be the easiest thing in the world to show her to be an
ordinary jealous woman whpse husband once lost his head and
made a fool of himself? Oh, no. Max — you’d have a difficult time
trying to prove anything against me.” She stood watching me, her
hands in her pockets and a smile on her face. “Do you realize that I
could get Danny to swear anything I asked her to swear? And that
the rest of the servants would follow her? They think we live
together at Manderley as husband and wife, don’t they? And so
does everyone, your friends, all our little world. Well, how are you
going to prove that we don’t?”
‘She sat down on the edge of the table, swinging her.leg,
watching me. “Haven’t we acted the parts of a loving husband and
wife rather too well?” she said. I remember watching that foot of
hers, swinging backwards and forwards, and my eyes and brain
began to burn. “We could make you look very foolish, Danny and
I,” she said softly. “We could make you look so foolish that no one
would believe you. Max, nobody at all.” Still that foot of hers was
swinging backwards and forwards. Suddenly she slipped off the
table and stood in front of me, smiling still, her hands in her
pockets.“If I had a child. Max, neither you nor anyone in the world
could prove that it was not yours. It would grow up here in
Manderley, bearing your name. There would be nothing you could
do. And when you died, Manderley would be his. You could not
prevent it. You would like that, wouldn’t you? You would enjoy it,
seeing my son asleep under the trees, playing on the grass, picking
flowers in the Happy Valley? You would love watching my son
grow bigger day by day, and knowing that when you died, all this
would be his?”
‘After a minute she went to the window. She began to laugh.
She went on laughing. I thought she would never stop. “God, how
funny! How beautifully funny! Well, you heard me say I was
going to change, didn’t you? Now you know the reason. They’ll be
happy, won’t they, all the people here? ‘It’s what we’ve always
hoped for, Mrs de Winter,’ they’ll say. I’ll be the perfect mother,
Max, as I’ve been the perfect wife. And none of them will ever
guess, none of them will ever know.”
‘She turned round and faced me, smiling, one hand in her
pocket. When I killed her she was smiling stiU. I fired at her heart.
The bullet passed right through her. She did not fall immediately.
She stood there looking at me, with that slow smile on her face, her
eyes wide open …
‘I had to get water from the bay,’ Maxim continued. ‘I had to
keep going for more. There was blood all round where she lay on
the floor. The wind began to blow harder, too.There was no hook
on the window. It kept banging backwards and forwards, while I
knelt there on the floor with that cloth, and the bucket of water
‘I carried her to the boat. It must have been half past eleven by
then, or nearly twelve. It was quite dark. There was no moon, the
wind was blowing hard at times, from the west. I carried her below
and left her there. Then I had to sail out of the little harbour against
the tide, vrith the rowing boat behind me. It was difficult. It was
blowing all right, but I was sheltered by the cliffi. I remember I got
the sail stuck. I hadn’t sailed, you see, for a long time. I never went
out with Rebecca. But I got the boat out into the bay, beyond the
cliff”. I tried to turn her, to get well away from the rocks. Suddenly
the wind blew harder; it tore the rope fix»m my hands. The sail
began to thunder and shake. I couldn’t remember what one had to
do – I couldn’t remember. I tried to reach the rope, but it was like a
whip in the air above my head. The wind was coming from in
fix>nt of us, and we were being blown back. It was dark – so dark
that I couldn’t see anything on the black, slippery boat. Somehow I
got down below. I had a heavy tool in my hand. If I didn’t do
something now, it would be
too late! Being blown like this, we would soon be out of deep water.
I drove the pointed tool into the bottom boards. It was heavy; it
split one of the boards right across. I pulled it out and drove the
point into another board. Then another. The water came up over
my feet. I left Rebecca there on the floor, and shut the windows
and the door. When I came back up I saw how near the shore we
had been driven by the wind. I climbed into the rowing boat, and
watched. She was sinking. The sails were still banging about, and I
thought someone would hear — someone walking on the cliffs late
at night, or some fishermen from Kerrith whose boat I could not
see. Her nose was sinking first. Then she turned over onto her side.
Suddenly she was not there any more. I remember staring at the
place where she had been. Then I rowed back to the harbour. It
started to rain.’
Maxim stopped, still staring straight in front of him. Then he .
turned to me.
‘That’s all,’ he said,‘there’s no more to tell. 1 walked up the path
through the woods. I went into the house. I remember undressing.
It was blowing and raining hard, off and on. 1 was sitting there on
the bed when Mrs Danvers knocked on the door.
1 went and opened it, in my night clothes, and spoke to her. She
was worried about Rebecca, but 1 told her to go back to bed. I shut
the door again. I went back and sat by the window, watching the
rain, listening to the sea down in the bay’
We sat there together without saying anything. I went on holding
his cold hands.
‘She sank too close in,’said Maxim.‘1 meant to take her right out
into the bay. They would never have found her there.’
‘It was the ship. They would never have found her if it were not
for the ship.’
‘She sank too close in,’ Maxim repeated.
We were silent again. 1 began to feel very tired.
‘1 knew it would happen one day,’ said Maxim. ‘It was only a
question of time. Finding you has not made any difference, has it?
Loving you does not change things at all. Rebecca knew she would
win in the end. I saw her smile, when she died.’ ‘Rebecca’s dead.
She can’t harm you any more.’
‘There’s her body. The diver has seen it. It’s lying there, on the
floor of the boat.’
‘We’ve got to explain it. We’ve got to. It must be the body of
someone you don’t know. Someone you have never seen before.’
‘Her things will still be there,’ he said. ‘The rings on her fingers.
Even if her clothes have decayed in the water, there wiO be
something there to tell them. It’s not like a body lost at sea, beaten
against the rocks.’
‘How will you 6nd out? How will you know?’
‘The diver is going down again at five in the morning. Searle has
made all the arrangements. They are going to try to raise the boat.
No one will be around. I’m going with them.’
‘Searle is going to try to get her back to Kerrith and put her on
the mud halfway up Kerrith harbour. He’ll get the water out of her.
He’s going to get hold of a doctor.’
‘If they find out it’s Rebecca, you must say the other body in the
church was a mistake – a terrible mistake.You must say that when
you went up to Ecjgecoombe you were ill, you didn’t know what
you were doing. You weren’t sure, even then. You will say that,
‘Yes,’ he said. ‘Yes.’
‘They can’t prove anything against you,’ I said. ‘Nobody saw you
that night. You had gone to bed. They can’t prove anything. No one
knows but you and I. No one at all. Not even Frank..We are the
only two people in the world to know, Maxim.You and I.’ ‘Yes,’ he
‘They’ll think the boat turned over and sank when Rebecca was
down below; they’ll think she went below for a rope or something,
and while she was there the wind came across the bay, and the boat
turned over, and Rebecca was trapped.They’ll think that, won’t
‘I don’t know,’ he said. ‘I don’t know.’
Suddenly the telephone began ringing in the little room behind
Maxim went in and shut the door. Robert came in to take away
the tea. I stood up, my back to him, so that he wouldn’t see my face.
I wondered when they would know – how long it would take for
the news to spread. When Robert had gone, Maxim came back into
‘It was Colonel Julyan. He’s just been talking to Searle. He’s
coming out to the boat with us tomorrow.’
‘Why Colonel Julyan? Why?’
‘He’s the Justice of the Peace* for Kerrith. He has to be present.’
‘What did he say?’
‘He asked me if 1 had any idea whose body it would be. 1 said I
didn’t know. I said we believed Rebecca to be alone. I said I didn’t
know of any friend.’
‘Did he say anything after that?’
‘He asked me if 1 thought it possible that 1 made a mistake when
I went up to Edgecoombe.’
‘He said that? He said that already?’
‘I said it might be possible, I didn’t know.’
‘He’ll be with you there tomorrow, when you look at the boat?
He, and Captain Searle, and a doctor?’
* Justice of the Peace: a person who judges cases in a local law court.
‘Inspector Welch, too.’
‘Why Inspector Welch?’
‘It’s the custom when a body has been found.’ He looked quickly
out of the window. ‘The wind has died away again.’
‘Yes,’ I said.
‘It will be a flat calm tomorrow for the diver,’ he said.
We dressed for dinner as usual. Afterwards we went back to the
library. We did not talk much – I sat on the floor at Maxim’s feet,
my head against his knees. There were no shadows between us any
more. I wondered how I could be so happy when the litde world
about us was so black. It was a strange sort of happiness. Not what I
had dreamed about. There was nothing feverish or urgent about it.
It was a quiet, still happjness.The library windows were wide open
and we looked out at the dark, dull sky.
At about half past eleven the next morning there was a message that
Maxim was bringing Frank and Colonel Julyan to lunch.
The morning dragged slowly on. It was very hot. I went upstairs
and changed into a thinner dress. Then I sat and waited. At five
minutes to one I heard the sound of a car in the drive, and voices. I
stood up, waiting for them to come into the room. In the mirror, my
face looked very pale. Maxim came in, and Frank and Colonel
‘How do you do?’ Colonel Julyan said. He spoke seriously and
quietly, like a doctor.
‘Give Colonel Julyan a drink,’ said Maxim, ‘we are just going to
Colonel Julyan did not have anything to drink. I took some, to
give me something to hold. He came and stood beside me at the
‘This is a most disturbing thing, Mrs de Winter,’ he said gently.
‘1 do feel for you and your husband very much.’
‘Thank you,’ I said. I put my glass down on the table. I was afraid
that he would notice that my hand was shaking.
‘What makes it so difficult is your nusband saying he recognized
the first body at Edgecoombe, over a year ago.’
‘I – 1 don’t quite understand.’
‘You didn’t hear, then, what we found this morning?’
‘I knew there was a body. The diver found a body.’
‘Yes.’Then, looking over his shoulder towards the door, ‘I’m
afraid it was her, without a doubt. I can’t go into details, but both
your husband and Dr Phillips were sure.’
He stopped suddenly and moved away from me. Maxim and
Frank had come back into the room.
‘Lunch is ready; shall we go in?’ said Maxim.
As we drank our coffee. Colonel Julyan started again in his quiet
way – I looked steadily at my plate. ‘I was saying to your wife
before lunch, de Winter, that the awkward part of this whole
business is the fact that you said you recognized that original body’
‘I think the mistake was very natural,’ said Frank quickly.‘It was
suggested that the body was hers when he was asked to go up to
Edgecoombe. Besides, Maocim was not well at the time. I wanted
to go with him, but he was determined to go alone. He was not in a
fit state to decide anything of the sort.’
‘That’s nonsense,’ said Maxim.‘I was perfectly well.’
‘Well, it’s no good going into аП that now. You recognized the
body, and now the only thing to do is to admit your mistake. There
seems to be no doubt about it this time. I wish you could be spared
a public inquiry, but I’m afraid that’s quite impossible. It needn’t
take very long. It’s just a matter of your saying you recognize the
body, and then getting Tabb, the boatbuilder, to say that the boat
was in good order when he last had her in his yard.
No, what worries me is the noise the newspapers will make about it.
So sad and unpleasant for you and your wife.’
‘That’s quite all right,’ said Maxim. ‘We understand.’
‘So unfortunate, that ship getting into trouble there. But for that,
the whole matter would have rested in peace. The only thing is, we
now know that Mrs de Winter’s death must have been sudden – not
the slow affair we imagined it to be. No question of trying to swim.’
‘None,’ said Maxim.
‘She must have gone below for something, and then the door
stuck, and suddenly a strong wind caught the boat with nobody on
the lookout. That seems to be the solution, don’t you think,
‘Oh, yes — undoubtedly,’ said Frank.
I looked up, and saw Frank looking at Maxim. He turned away
again immediately, but not before I had seen and understood the
expression in his eyes. Frank knew. And Maxim did not know that
he knew. I went on drinking my coffee. My hand holding the cup
was hot and wet.
‘I suppose sooner or later we all make a mistake in judgment,’
said Colonel Julyan. ‘Mrs de Winter must have known how the
wind comes round the cliff in that bay; it wasn’t safe to leave a small
boat like that and go down below. She must have sailed alone over
that spot many times. Then, just once, she took a chance — and the
chance killed her.’
‘Accidents happen so easily,’ said Frank, ‘even to the most
‘Yes. But if Mrs de Winter hadn’t gone below, the accident
would never have happened. A strange thing to do. I never knew
her to make a mistake in a boat. That was the sort of thing only a
beginner would do.’
‘It was blowing hard that night. Something may have got stuck.
And then she slipped down for a knife.’
‘Of course. Of course. Well, we shall never know. As 1 said, 1
wish I could stop the inquiry, but I can’t. It will be as short as
possible. But I’m afraid we shan’t be able to keep the newspaper
reporters out of it.’
I did not look at Frank when he said goodbye; I was afraid he
would understand my eyes. I did not want him to know that I
When they had gone, Maxim said: ‘It’s going to be all right. I’m
quite confident.You saw how Julyan was at lunch, and Frank.
There won’t be any difficulty at the inquiry. It’s going to be all
1 did not say anything. I held his arm tightly.
‘There was never any question of the body being someone
unknown. It was quite obvious this morning. What we saw was
enough for Dr Phillips to recognize her, even without me.There
was no sign of what I had done. The bullet had not touched the
bone.You heard what they said; they think she was trapped there,
down below. They will believe that at the inquiry, too. Dr Phillips
will tell them.’
He paused. Still I did not speak.
‘I only mind for you,’ he said. ‘If it had to come all over again, ‘ I
would not do anything different. I’m glad I killed Rebecca. 1 shall
never be sorry for that, never, never. But you! 1 can’t forget what it
has done to you. It’s gone for ever, that funny, young, lost look that I
loved. It won’t come back again. I killed that, too, when I told you
about Rebecca . . . It’s gone, in twenty-four hours.You are so much
It was in all the papers the next day. Pictures of Maxim, and of
Manderley. They described Rebecca as beautiful, clever, popular,
and Maxim as marrying again the following spring and bringing his
young wife to Manderley, giving a big fancy-dress dance for
1 must try to get out of the door. There was no air in the place ..
.They were talking. Someone in front of me was standing up, and I
couldn’t see anything. It was hot, so very hot. Maxim was standing
up now. I could not look at him.
‘Mr de Winter, you heard the statement from James Tabb. Do
you know anything of these holes in the boat?’
‘Nothing at all.’
‘Mr de Winter, I want you to believe that we all feel for you in
this matter. No doubt you have suffered a shock, a great shock, in
learning that your wife was found in her boat, and not at sea, as you
supposed. I am inquiring into the matter for you. I want to find out
exactly how and why she died. James Tabb has just said that the
boat had three holes hammered through her bottom. Do you doubt
‘Of course not. He’s a boatbuilder. He knows what he’s talking
‘Who looked after Mrs de Winter’s boat?’
‘She looked after it herself.’
‘She employed no man to help her?’
‘No, nobody at all.’
‘The boat was kept in the private harbour at Manderley?’
‘Any stranger who tried to damage the boat would be seen?
There is no public footpath to the harbour?’
‘Yet James Tabb has told us that a boat with those holes
hammered in her probably could not float for more than ten
‘So that the boat cannot have been damaged before Mrs de
Winter took her out, or she would have sunk in the harbour?’ ‘No
‘Therefore we must suppose that whoever took the boat out
that night made the holes in her?’
‘You have told us already that the door was shut, the windows
also, and your wife’s remains were on the floor. This was in your
statement, and in Doctor PhiUips’s, and in Captain Searle’s.’
‘And now comes the statement that with some sharp instrument
three holes had been made in the bottom. Does this not strike you
as very strange?’
‘You have no suggestion to make?’
‘None at all.’
‘Mr de Winter, painful as it may be, it is my duty to ask you a
very personal question. Were the relations between you and your
first wife perfectly happy?’
It was hot, so hot, with all these people. No open window.The
door was further away than I had thought, and all the time the
ground coming up to meet me.
And then came Maxim’s voice, clear and strong: ‘Will someone
take my wife outside? She’s going to faint.’
Chapter 9 Favell Accuses Maxim
I was sitting in the little room again – the room like a waiting room
at a station. The policeman was there, giving me a glass of water,
and someone’s hand was on my arm, Frank’s hand. I sat quite still,
the floor, the walls, Frank and the policeman coming into place in
front of me.
‘I’m so sorry,’ I said.‘Such a stupid thing to do. It was so hot in
‘It gets very airless in there,’ said the policeman. ‘We’ve had
ladies fainting in there before.’
, ‘Are you feeling better, Mrs de Winter?’ said Frank.
‘Yes. Yes. Much better: I shall be all right now Don’t wait with me.’
‘I’m gomg to take you back to Manderley.’
, ‘Yes. Maxim has asked me to.’
‘I want to wait for him.’
‘Maxim may be a long time.’
Why did he say that? What did he mean? Why didn’t he look at me?
He took my arm and walked with me down the steps into the street.
Maxim may be a long time …
We did not speak. We drove away towards Manderley.
‘Why will they be a long time? What are they going to do?’ ‘They
may have to go over the facts again.’
‘They’ve had all the facts.There’s nothing more anyone can say.’
‘You never know. Tabb’s statement has changed everything. They
may have to do it in a different way.’
‘What way? What do you mean?’
‘You heard what Tabb said about the boat? They won’t believe it
was an accident now.’
‘It’s all wrong, Frank! They shouldn’t listen to*Tabb. How can he
tell, after all these months, how holes were made in the boat? What are
they trying to prove?’
‘I don’t know.’
‘They’ll go on questioning Maxim, making hint lose his temper,,
making him say things he doesn’t mean. They’ll ask question after
question, Frank, and Maxim won’t be able to stand – it. I know he
won’t stand it!’
Frank did not answer. He was driving very fast. That meant he was
worried, very worried.
‘That man was there – that man who came to Manderley to see Mrs
‘You mean Favell? Yes, I saw him.’
‘He was sitting there with Mrs Danvers.’
‘Why was he there? What right had he to go?’
‘He was her cousin.’
‘It’s not right that he and Mrs Danvers should sit there, listening.
I don’t trust them, Frank.’
‘They might do something; they might make troubk.’
Again Frank did not answer. I realized that he was too loyal to
Maxim to be drawn into a discussion, even with me. He did not
know how much I knew. We were friends, we travelled the same
road, but we dared not look at one another. Neither of us d^ired
risk saying what we knew.
In my room, I lay down on my bed. Perhaps they would
question Frank as well — ask him about that evening, over twelve
months ago, when Maxim had had dinner at his house. The exact
time that Maxim left. Whether anybody saw Maxim when he got
back to Manderley. Whether anyone could prove that Maxim went
straight upstairs to bed. Mrs Danvers might be called on. She might
be questioned. And Maxim beginning to lose his temper, beginning
to turn white .. .
I must have fallen asleep, because I woke suddenly at the first
crack of thunder. I sat up. The hands on the clock were pointing to
five. I went to the window. There was not a breath of wind. The
leaves hung still, waiting. The sky was grey. More thunder in the
distance. No rain fell. I went down to the hbrary and at naif past
five Robert came in.
‘The car has just driven up to the door now, madam.’
‘Mr de Winter’s car, madam.’
‘Is Mr de Winter driving it himself?’
I tried to get up, but my legs were weak; they would not hold
her, and then the next morning the body, of his first wife being
found, trapped in her sailing boat at the bottom of the bay. It made a
I thought of all the things they could say, if they knew the truth.
All over the front page. Newsboys shouting in the streets. That
terrible six-letter word printed large and black …
Frank came up after breakfast. He looked pale and tired, as
though he had not slept. Tve told them to put all telephone calls for
Manderley through to the office,’ he said. ‘If those newspapermen
ring up, I can deal with them.’
‘We all want to kick them, but you’ve got to see their point of
view. It’s their job. But you won’t have to see them or speak to
them, Maxim. All you have to think about is your statement at the
‘I know what to say’
‘Of course you do. But don’t forget that old Horridge will be in
charge. He’s an awkward sort of man. Likes to go into details just to
show how thorough he is.You mustn’t let him worry you.’
‘Why the devil should I be worried? I have nothing to be
‘Of course not. But I’ve been to these inquiries before, and it’s
easy to get annoyed. You don’t want to lose your temper.’
‘Frank’s right,’ I said. ‘I know just what he means. The more
quickly and smoothly the whole thing goes, the easier it will be for
everyone. Then, once it’s over, we’ll forget all about it, and so wiO
everyone else, won’t they, Frank?’
‘Yes, of course,’ said Frank.
I still avoided his eye, but I was surer than ever that he knew the
truth. He had always known it. From the very beginning.
Chapter 8 The Inquiry
On the way to the inquiry Maxim was quite calm. It was like going
with someone to hospital – someone who was going to have an
operation – and not knowing what would happen, not knowing whether
the operation would be successful. My hands were very cold. My heart
was beating strangely. When we got there,*I decided not to go in, but
to wait outside in the car.
It was early-closing day. The shops looked dull and there wefe very
few people about. I sat looking at the silent shops as the minutes went
by. I wondered what was happening. I got out of the car, and began
walking up and down. Somehow, without wanting to, I came to the
building where the inquiry was being held.
A policeman appeared from nowhere.
‘You can’t wait here.’
Tm sorry,’ I said, turning away. ,
‘Oh, excuse me, madam; of course, you’re Mrs de Winter, aren’t
you? You can wait in here if you like.’
He showed me into a small empty room, like a waiting-room at a
railway station. I sat there. Five ininutes passed and nothing happened.
It was worse than being outside in the car. I got up and went inte the
passage. The policeman was standing there.
‘How long will they be?’
‘I’ll go and inquire, if you like.’
In a moment he was back again.‘I don’t think they’ll be very much
longer,’ he said.‘Mr de Winter has just made his statement. Captain
Searle, the diver and Dr Phillips have given theirs.There’s only one
more to speak. Mr Tabb, the boatbuilder.’
‘Then it’s nearly over?’
‘I expect so, madam. Would you like to hear the rest of it? There’s a
chair just inside the door. If you slip in now, nobody will notice you.’
‘Yes,’ I said. ‘Yes. I think I will.’
I followed the policeman, slipped in, and sat down just by the
door. The room was smaller than 1 had imagined, and very hot.
There were people there that 1 did not know; 1 looked at them out
of the corner of my eye. My heart gave a jump suddenly as I
recognized Mrs Danvers. And Favell was beside her. Jack Favell,
Rebecca’s cousin. 1 had not expected him to be there. JamesTabb,
the boatbuilder, was standing up now, answering questions.
‘Was the boat in a fit state to put to sea?’
‘She was when 1 fixed her up in April of last year. That would be
Mrs de Winter’s fourth season with the boat.’
‘Had the boat ever been known to turn over before?’
‘No, sir. I should soon have heard from Mrs de Winter if there
had been any question of it. She was pleased with the boat in every
way, from what she said to me.’
‘I suppose great care was needed in handling the boat?’
‘Well, sir, everyone has to be careful, sailing a boat, it’s true. But
this one was a strong, well-built boat,^and could stand a lot of
wind. Mrs de Winter had sailed her in worse weather than that
night. Why, it was only blowing now and again. That’s what I said
all along. I couldn’t understand her boat going down on a night like
‘But, surely, if Mrs de Winter went below for a coat, as is
supposed, and a sudden strong wind were to come round that cliff,
it would be enough to turn the boat over?’
James Tabb shook his head.‘No., 1 don’t believe that it would.’
‘Well, I’m afraid that’s what must have happened. I don’t think Mr
de Winter or any of us suggest that you were to blame at all. You
fixed the boat up at the beginning of the season, you say she was in
good condition, and that’s all I want to know. It seems that Mrs de
Winter was careless for a moment, and she lost her life, the boat
sinking with her on board. Such things have happened before. 1
repeat, we are not blaming you.’
‘Excuse me, sir,’ said the boatbuilder, ‘but there’s a bit more to it
than that. And if you’ll allow me. I’d like to make a further
‘Very well. Go on.’
‘It’s like this, sir. After the accident last year, a lot of people in
Kerrith said I had let Mrs de Winter start the season in a damaged
boat that let the water in. I lost some work because of it. It was very
unfair, but the boat had sunk, and there was nothing I could say to
defend myself. Well, I went to have a look at her yesterday.
I wanted to satisfy myself that the work I had done was all right.’
‘Well, that was very natural. I hope you were satisfied.’
‘Yes, sir, I was. There was nothing wrong with my work. I
examined it all. She’d sunk onto sand. I asked the diver about that,
and he told me so. She hadn’t touched the rocks.They were one and
a half metres away. She was lying on sand, and there wasn’t the
mark of a rock on her.’
‘Well? Is that all you want to say?’
‘No. It’s not. What I want to know is this.Who made the holes in
her? Rocks didn’t do it. The nearest rock was one and a half metres
away. Besides, they weren’t the sort of holes made by a rock. They
were made with some pointed tool. On purpose.’
I did not look at him. I looked at the floor. It was hot – much too
hot. Why didn’t they open a window? I wondered why no one said
anything. Why did the silence last so long?
‘What do you mean? What holes?’The voice sounded very far
‘There were three of them. Driven through her with something
sharp. With those holes in her, it wouldn’t take long for a small
boat like her to sink. Not ten minutes, I should say. Those holes
were not there when the boat left my boatyard. It’s my opinion, sir,
that the boat never turned over at all. She was sunk on purpose.’
‘Oh yes?’ he said. ‘In what way can you make things dangerous?’
‘Look here. Max, you know all about Rebecca and me. We were
lovers, weren’t we? I’ve never lied about it. Very well then. Up to
now I believed, like every other fool, that Rebecca was drowned
sailing in the bay, and that her body was picked up at Edgecoombe,
weeks afterwards.’ He paused, and sat there, looking at each one of
us in turn. ‘Then I picked up the evening paper a few days ago and
read that Rebecca’s boat had been found, and that there was a body
down below. I couldn’t understand it; Who would Rebecca have as
a sailing companion? It didn’t make sense.
I came down here and stayed at a hotel. I got in touch with Mrs
Danvers. She told me that the body -was Rebecca’s. Even so, I
thought, like everyone else, that the first body was a mistake, and
that Rebecca had somehow got shut in when she went down to get
a coat. Well, I went to the inquiry today, as you know. And
everything went smoothly, didn’t it, until Tabb spoke? But after
that? Well, Max, old man, what have you got to say about those
holes hammered in the bottom of the boat?’
‘Do you think,’ said Maxim slowly,‘that after all those hours of
talk this afternoon I am going through it again – with you? You
heard the inquiry. That must satisfy you.’
‘Killed herself, eh? Rebecca killed herself? The sort of thing she
would do, was it? Listen; you never knew I had this note, did you? I
kept it, because it was the last thing she ever wrote to me. I’ll read it
to you. 1 think it will interest you.’
He took a piece of paper out of his pocket. “‘I tried to telephone
you from the flat,”’ he read,“‘but could get no answer. I’m going
down to Manderley right away. I shall be at the cottage this
evening, and if you get this in time, will you get the car and follow
me? I’ll spend the night at the cottage, and leave the door open for
you. I’ve got something to tell you and I want to see you as soon as
possible. Rebecca.’” He put the note back in his
pocket. ‘That’s not the sort of note you write when you’re going to
kill yourself, is it? It was waiting for me at my flat when I got back
at about four in the morning. I had no idea Rebecca was going to be
in London that day, or I would have got in touch with her. As it
was, 1 was at a party that night. When I read the note I decided it
was too late to start.driving for six hours down to Manderley. I
went to bed, determined to put through a call later in the day. I did.
And I learnt that Rebecca had been drowned!’
He sat there, looking at Maxim.
‘Supposing I had produced that note at the inquiry this
afternoon, it would have been awkward for you, wouldn’t it, Max,
‘Well – why didn’t you?’
‘Steady, old boy. No need to get worried! You’ve never been a
friend to me, but I don’t mind. AH married men with lovely wives
are jealous, aren’t they? I don’t blame them. Now, Max, I’ve laid all
my cards on the table.Why can’t we come to some agreement? I’m
not a rich man – I’m top fond of taking risks for that. But what
worries me is not having anything in the bank to fall back, on.
Now, if I had a settlement of two or three thousand pounds a year
for life I could get along quite comfortably. And I’d never trouble
you again. I swear 1 wPuldn’t.’
‘I’ve asked’you to leave the house,’said M4xim.‘I’m not going to
ask you again. There’s the door.You can open it yourself’
‘Half a minute, Maxim,’ said Frank, ‘it’s not quite so easy as that.’
He turned to Favell, ‘I see what you’re after. It happens,
unfortunately, that you could twist things round and make it
difficult for Maxim. 1 don’t think he sees that as clearly as I do.
What is the exact amount you suggest that Maxim should settle on
I saw Maxim go white. ‘Don’t get involved with this, Frank,’ he
said,‘this is my affair. I’m not going to give way to threats.You
think you can frighten me, don’t you, Favell? Well, you’re wrong. I’m
not afraid of anything you can do. Shall I ring up Colonel Julyan and
ask him to come over? He’s the Justice of the Peace. He’ll be
interested in your story.’
Favell looked hard at him, then he laughed.
‘A good try,’ he said,‘but it won’t work.You wouldn’t dare ring up
old Julyan! I’ve enough here to hang you. Max, old man.’ Maxim
walked slowly across the library, and into the little room beyond.
‘Stop him!’ I said to Frank.’‘Stop him, please!’
Frank went over to him quickly. I heard Maxim’s voice, very cook
very calm. ‘I want Kerrith 17,’ he said. Favell was watching the door.
‘Leave me alone!’ I heard Maxim say to Frank.Then – ‘Is that Colonel
Julyan? It’s de Winter here. Yes. Yes, I know. I wonder if you could
possibly come over to Manderley immediately? It’s, rather urgent. I
can’t explain why, on the telephone, but you’ll hear everything when
you come. I’m sorry to have to drag you out.Yes. Thank you very
much, goodbye.’ • He came back again into the room.‘Julyan is
coming now,’ he said. He went to the windows and threw them open. It
was still raining very hard. He stood there with his back to lis,
breathing the cold air. We none of us said anything. There was no
sound but the falling rain. I felt helpless.There was nothing I could do.
I had to sit there, watching the rain. ^
It was raining too hard to hear the car. We did not know Colonel
Julyan had arrived until the door opened, and Frith showed him in.
‘I think you realize,’ Maxim said, ‘that I haven’t brought you out on
an evening like this for a social half-hour before dinner. This is Jack
Favell, my first wife’s cousin. Go ahead, Favell.’
Favell got up. The short wait seemed to have calmed him. He was
not smiling any longer. I had the feeling that he was not too pleased at
the way things had happened, and was not ready for
Colonel Julyan. He began speaking in a loud and unpleasant
voice.‘Look here, Colonel Julyan, I’ll come straight to the point.
The reason why I’m here is that I am not satisfied with the result of
the inquiry this afternoon.’
‘Oh?’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘Isn’t that for de Winter to say?’ ‘No, I
don’t think it is. I have a right to speak, not only as Rebecca’s
cousin, but as the man she would have married, if she had lived.’
Colonel Julyan looked very surprised. ‘I see. Is this true, de
‘It’s the first I’ve heard of it,’ said Maxim.
Colonel Julyan looked from one to the other doubtfully. ‘Look
here, Favell,’ he said, ‘what exactly is your trouble?’
Favell stared at him a moment. I could see that he was planning
something in his mind, but had had too much to drink to be able to
carry it out. He put his hand in his pocket and brought out
Rebecca’s note. ‘This note was written a few hours before Rebecca
is supposed to have set out to kill herself at sea. Here it is. Read it,
and say whether you think the woman who wrote that note had
made up her mind to kill herself.’
Colonel Julyan read the note.Then he handed it back.‘No. On
the face of it, no. But 1 don’t know what she was going to tell you.
Perhaps you do – or perhaps de Winter does?’
Maxim said nothing.
‘My cousin made a definite appointment in that note, didn’t she?
She clearly asked me to drive down to Manderley that night
because she had something to tell me. She made the appointment,
and she was to spend the night in the qottage on purpose to see me
alone. The fact of her going for a sail does not surprise me – it was
the sort of thing she did after a long day in London. But to hammer
holes in the floor of the boat and drown herself — oh no. Colonel
Julyan, by God no!’The colour had flooded into his face, and the
last words were shouted.
me up. I stood leaning against a chair. My throat was very dry.
After a minute Maxim came in. He stood just inside the door.
He looked tired, old. There were lines at the corners of his
mouth I had never noticed before.
‘It’s all over,’ he said.
I waited. Still I could not speak or move towards him.
‘She killed herself… they were all in the dark, of course. They
didn’t know what to do.’
‘Killed herself?’ I sat down on the chair. ‘But why?’ –
‘Goodness knows! They did not seem to think it necessary to
decide. Old Horridge, going on at me – wanting to know if Rebecca
had any money troubles. Money troubles!’
He went and stood by the window, looking out at the green
grass.‘It’s going to rain. Thank God, it’s going to rain at last.’
‘What happened? What did Horridge say? Why have you been
there all this time?’
‘He went over and over the same ground again,’ said Maxim.
‘Little details about the boat that nobody cared about. I thought I
would go mad. I kept my temper, though. Seeing you there by the
door made me remember what I had to do. If you hadn’t fainted
like that, I would never have done it. The shock reminded me, and
then I knew exactly what I h^d to say. I never took my eyes off old
Horridge – I shall remember his face until my dying day. I’m so
tired I can’t see or hear or feel anything.’
He sat down, his head in his hands. I went and sat beside him.
‘Where’s Frank?’ I asked.
‘He had to go to the church. I would have gone, too, but I
wanted to come straight back to you. I kept thinking of you,
waiting, all by yourself, not knowing what was going to happen.’
‘Why the church?’
‘We have to do something there this evening.’
Then I understood. They were going to bury Rebecca.
‘It’s fixed for half past six. There won’t be anybody hanging
about. It was arranged yesterday. The inquiry doesn’t make any ‘
He looked tired, so deathly tired.
‘I wish you didn’t have to go out again,’ I said.
‘It won’t take long.’
Til come with you. I shan’t mind. Let me come with you.’
‘No. I don’t want you to come.’
Then he left me, and I heard the sound of the car becoming
fainter. Just after seven the rain began to fall. Gendy at first, and so
lighdy that I could not see it. Then louder and faster. I left the
windows wide open, stood in front of them and breathed the cold,
clean air. The rain fell on my face and hands. It came down thick
and fast, so that I could not even see the trees.
I did not hear Frith come in at the door.
‘Excuse me, madam, but do you know if Mr de Winter will be
‘No. Not very long.’
‘There’s a gendem^n to see him, madam.’ He paused. ‘I’m not
quite sure what I ought to say. He’s determined to see Mr de
‘Who is it? Anyone you know?’
Frith looked uncomfortable.‘Yes, madam. It’s a gentleman who
used to come here frequendy at one time. A Mr Favell.’
I turned and shut the window. The rain was coming in on the
cushions.Then I looked at Frith.‘I think perhaps I had better see Mr
FavcU,’ I said.
/Very good, madam.’
I went and stood beside the empty fireplace. It was just possible
that I would be able to get rid of Favell before Maxim came back.
I did not know what I was going to say to him, but I was not
In a few moments Frith showed him in. He looked rather
untidy. His eyes looked red. I wondered if he had been drinking.
‘I’m afraid Maxim isn’t here,’ I said.’I don’t know when he will
be back. Wouldn’t it be better if ypu saw him at the office in the
‘Waiting doesn’t worry me,’ said Favell, ‘and I don’t think I shall
have to wait very long. I had a look in the dining room as I came
along, and I see Max is expected to dinner all right.’
‘Our plans have been changed; it’s quite possible that Maxim
won’t be home at all this evening.’
‘He’s run off, has he?’said Favell with a half-smile I did not like.
‘I wonder if you really mean it! TeU me, are you feeling better? Too
bad, fainting like that this afternoon. 1 would have come to help,
but I saw you had someone to help you. 1 expect Frank Crawley
enjoyed himself. Did you let him drive you home? You wouldn’t let
me drive you five metres!’
‘What do you want to see Maxim about?’
‘You’ve grown up a bit since I saw you last, haven’t you? I
wonder what you’ve been doing? I don’t think I shall mind very
much if Max doesn’t get back to dinner! What do you say?’- ‘Mr
Favell,’ I said, ‘I don’t want to be rude, but I’m very tired – I’ve had
a long day. If you can’t tell me what you want to see Maxim about,
it’s not much good your sitting here. You had far better do as I
suggest, and go round to the office in the morning.’ ‘No. No. No.
Don’t run away and leave me! I’m quite harmless, really I am. And I
think you are behaving very well over this, really very well. I take
my hat off to you – I really do.’ His speech was very thick. I wished
I had never told Frith I would see him.
‘You come down here to Manderley,’ he said, -waving his arm
rather wildly, ‘you take on all this place, meet hundreds of people
you’ve never seen before, you put up with old Max and his temper,
you don’t give in to anyone, you just go your own way, I call it a
good effort, and I don’t care who hears me say so. A good effort.’ He
steadied himself against the table. ‘This business has
been a shock to me, you know. A terrible shock. Rebecca was my
cousin. I was very fond of her. Always great friends. Liked the same
things, the same people. Laughed at the same jokes. I suppose I was
fonder of Rebecca than of anyone else in the world. And she was
fond of me. All this has been a great shock.’ ‘Yes,’ I said. ‘I’m very
sorry for you.’
‘And what is Max going to do about it? That’s what I want to
know. Does he think he can sit back quietly now that the inquiry is
over? Tell me that.’ He was not smiling any more. He bent towards
me. ‘I’m going to see that justice is done for Rebecca. Killed
herself]’ He leaned closer to me.‘You and I know she didn’t, don’t
we?’ He leaned closer to me still. ‘Don’t we?’ he said slowly.
The door opened and Maxim came into the room, with Frank
just behind him. Maxim stood quite still, with the door open.
‘What the devil are you doing here?’ he said.
Favell turned, his hands in his pockets.Then he began to smile.
‘As a matter of fact. Max, old man, I came to congratulate you on
the result of the inquiry this afternoon.’
‘Do you mind leaving the house?’ said Maxim. ‘Or do you want
Crawley and me to throw you out?’
‘Steady a moment, steady a moment!’ said Favell. He sat down
on the arm of a chair. ‘You don’t want Frith to hear what I’m going
to say, do you? Well, he will, if you don’t shut that door.’ • Maxim
did^not move. I saw Frank close the door very quietly. ‘Now listen
here. Max,’ said Favell, ‘you’ve come out of this affair very well,
haven’t you? Oh yes, I was at the inquiry this afternoon. I was there
from start to finish — I saw your wife faint, at a rather important
moment, and I don’t blame her. It could have gone either way for
you. Max, couldn’t it? And lucky for you that it went the way it did.
You realize, don’t you. Max old man, that I can make things very
unpleasant for you if I choose. Not only unpleasant, but – shall I say
Still Maxim did not move. He never took his eyes off Favell.
I could see”that Colonel Julyan did ndt like Favell.‘My dear man,
it’s not the slightest use your losing your temper with me. You say
you refuse to believe that your cousin kiUed herself. But you heard
what the boatbuilder said. The holes were there. Suppose we get to
the point. What do you suggest really happened?’
Favell turned his head and looked slowly towards Maxim. He
was twisting the note between his fingers. ‘Rebecca never made
those holes. She never killed herself. Rebecca was murdered. And if
you want to know who the murderer is, there he stands, by the
window there! He couldn’t even wait, could he, until a year had
passed, before marrying the first girl he set eyes on. There’s your
murderer for you, Mr Maximilian de Winter.Take a long look at
him. He’d look well hanging, wouldn’t he?’
And Favell began to laugh, the laugh of a man who had been
drinking, high and foolish, all the time twisting Rebecca’s note
between his fingers.
Thank God for Favefi’s laugh. Thank God for his pointing finger,
his red face, his wild eyes. Thank God for thd way he stood there,
rocking slightly on his feet. It put Colonel Julyan on our side.
‘The man’s been drinking,’ he said quietly. ‘He doesn’t know
what he’s saying.’
‘Been drinking, have I?’ shouted FaveU.‘Oh, no, my fine friend.
You may be a Justice of the Peace and a colonel too, but that means
nothing to me. I’ve got the law on my side, for a change, and I’m
going to use it. There are other Justices of the Peace besides you.
Men vvith brains in their heads. Max de Winter murdered Rebecca,
and I’m going to prove it.’
‘Wait a minute, Mr Favell,’ said Colonel Julyan quietly, ‘you
were at the inquiry this afternoon. If you felt so deeply about it,
why didn’t you produce that letter in court?’
Favell looked hard at him, then laughed. ‘Because I didn’t
choose to, that’s why. I preferred to come and deal with de Winter
‘That’s why I asked you to come here,’ said Maxim, walking
forward from the window. ‘I asked him the same question. He said he
was not a rich man, and that if I cared to settle two or three thousand a
year on him for life he would never worry me again. Frank was here,
and my wife. They both heard him. Ask them.’
‘It’s perfecdy true, sir,’ said Frank.
‘Mr Favell,’said Colonel Julyan.‘You have just made a serious
accusation against Mr de Winter. Have you any proof?’
‘Proof?’ said Favell. ‘What the devil do you want with proof?
Aren’t those holes in the boat proof enough?’
‘Certainly not, unless you can produce a witness who saw him do it.
Where’s your witness?’
‘Witness! Who else would kill Rebecca? I tell you de Winter killed
Rebecca because of me. He knew I was her lover; he was madly
jealous. He knew she was waiting for me at the cottage, and he went
down that night and killed her. Then he put her body in the boat and
‘Quite a clever story, Favell, in its way, but you have no proof.
Produce a witness who saw it happen, and I might begin to take you
‘Wait a minute,’ said Favell, ‘wait a minute . . . There’s quite a good
chance that de Winter might have been seen that night.’
I suddenly knew what Favell meant. And in a flash of fear and
horror I knew that he was right. Litde sentences came back to me.
‘She’s down there all right. She’ll not come back again.’ ‘The fishes
have eaten her up by now, haven’t they?’ Ben had seen! Ben, with his
poor, foolish brain, had been a witness all the time.
‘There’s a local man who spends his time on the shore. He was
often around when I was down there with Rebecca. He used to sleep in
the woods in hot weather. The man’s a fool, and would
never have come forward on his own. But I can make him talk if he
did see anything that night, and there’s a good chance he did.’ ‘He
must mean Ben,’ said Frank, with a quick look at Maxim. ‘He’s the
son of one of our men. But he§ not responsible for what he says or
does. He’s not very intelligent.’
‘What the devil does that matter?’ said Favell. ‘He’s got eyes,
hasn’t he? He knows what he sees. He’s only got to answer yes or
‘Can we get hold of this man and question him?’ asked Colonel
‘Of course. Drive down to his mother’s cottage, Frank, and bring
him back. We want to end this thing, don’t we?’
The door opened, and Frank came in. He turned and spoke to
someone in the hall outside.
‘All right, Ben,’ he said quietly. ‘There’s nothing to be frightened
Ben came awkwardly into the room. He looked strange without
his hat. I realized for the first time that he had no hair. He looked
different, horrible. The light seemed to confuse him. He looked
foolishly round the room.
Then Favell walked towards him. ‘Hullo,’ he said, ‘how has life
treated you since we last met?’
Ben looked at him, giving no sign that he recognized him. He did
‘Well?’ said Favell. ‘You know who I am, don’t you?’
‘You know who I am, don’t you?’
Colonel Julyan walked across to him. ‘You shall go home in a few
minutes, Ben. No one’s going to hurt you. We just want you to
answer one or two questions.You know Mr Favell, don’t you?’
This time Ben shook his head. ‘I never seen him,’ he said.
‘Don’t be a fool; you know you’ve seen me! You’ve seen me go to the
cottage on the shore. Haven’t you?’
‘No,’ said Ben. ‘I never seen no one.’
‘A useful witness!’ said Colonel Julyan.
Favell swung round on him. ‘Someone has got at this fool and paid
him. I tell you he’s seen me lots of times.’
‘I never seen you,’ said Ben.Then he took hold of Frank’s arm.
‘Has he come to take me to the madhouse? I don’t want to go to the
madhouse. They’re cruel to people in there. I want to stay at home.
I done nothing.’
‘That’s all right, Ben,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘No one’s going to put
you in the madhouse. Now, you remember the lady who had the
‘Yes, we know that. She used to sail the boat, didn’t she? Were
you on the shore when she saded it the last time — when she didn’t
come back again?’
‘You were there, weren’t you?’ said Favell. ‘You saw Mrs de
Winter come down to the cottage, and later you saw Mr de Winter,
too. He went into the cottage after her. What happened then? Go
on. What happened?’
Ben drew back against the wall. ‘I seen nothing. I want to stay at
home. I’m not going to the madhouse. I’ve never seen you. Never
before.’ He began to cry like a child.
‘Your witness doesn’t seem to have helped you,’ said Colonel Julyan.
‘He’s been paid,’ shouted Favell.‘Paid to tell his string of hes.’ Frank
took Ben out of the room. ‘The man seemed to be frightened,’ said
Colonel Julyan to Maxim. ‘I was watching him. He’s never been treated
badly, has he?’
‘No,’ said Maxim.‘He’s perfectly harmless. I’ve always let him do as
‘He’s been frightened at some time,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘He was
showing the whites of his eyes – just like a dog does when you’re
going to whip him.’
‘Well, why didn’t you?’ said Favell.’He’d have remembered me
all right if you had whipped him.’
‘He hasn’t helped you, has he?’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘You say you
were going to marry Mrs de Winter, and that you used to meet her
secredy in the cottage. You can’t evea prove that story, can you?’
‘Can’t I?’ said Favell. I saw him smile. He came across to the
fireplace and rang the bell.
I guessed what was going to happen. Frith answered the bell.
‘Ask Mrs Danvers to come here,’ said Favell. Then he turned to
Colonel Julyan. ‘Mrs Danvers was Rebecca’s personal friend. She
was with her for years before she married.You will find her a very
different sort of witness from Ben.’
Frank looked quickly at Maxim. Colonel Julyan saw the look,
and his lips tightened. I did not like it.
We all waited, watching the door. Mrs Danvers came into the
room and stood by the door, her hands folded in front of her,
looking from one to the other of us.
‘First of all, Mrs Danvers, 1 want to ask you a question,’ said
Colonel Julyan. ‘Did you know of the relationship between the late
Mrs de Winter and Mr Favell here?’
‘They were cousins,’ said Mrs Danvers.
‘I mean something closer than t;hat.’
‘I’m afraid I don’t understand, sir.’
‘Oh, nonsense, Danny!’ said Favell. ‘Ypu know what he means.
You know Rebecca and I had lived together on and off for years,
hadn’t we? She was in love with me, wasn’t she?’
Mrs Danvers looked at him for a moment: ‘She was not.’ ‘Listen
to me, you old-’ began Favell, but Mrs Danvers cut him . short. ‘She
was not in love with you, or with Mr de Winter. She
was not in love with anyone. She hated men. She was above all
Favell said angrily; ‘Now, listen. Didn’t she come through the
woods to meet me, night after night? Didn’t you wait up for her?
Didn’t she spend the weekends with me in London?’
‘Well,’ said Mrs Danvers with sudden anger, ‘and what if she
did? She had a right to amuse herself, hadn’t she? Lovemaking was
a game with her — only a game. She told me so. She did it because
it made her laugh. It made her laugh, I tell you! She laughed at you
as she laughed at all the rest. I’ve known her come back and sit
upstairs in bed and rock with laughtet at the lot of you.’
There was something horrible in the sudden rush of words,
something horrible and unexpected. It made me feel sick, even
though I knew. Maxim had gone very white. Favell looked at her
foolishly, as though he had not understood. There was no sound
but that of the falling rain. Then Colonel Julyan spoke, quiedy,
‘Mrs Danvers, can you think of any reason at all why Mn de
Winter would have taken her own life?’
‘No,’ she said, shaking her head. ‘No.’
‘There, you see?’ said Favell quickly.‘It’s impossible. She knows
that as well as I do.’
‘Be quiet, will you? Give Mrs Danvers time to think. She wrote
that note some time during those hours she spent in London. There
was something she wanted to tell you. Let Mrs Danvers read the
She read it twice, shaking her head.‘It’s no use,’she said.‘I don’t
know what she meant. If there was something important she had to
tell Mr Jack she would have told me first.’
‘Does anybody know how she spent that flay in London?’ Favell
swore under his breath. ‘Look here, she left that note at my flat at
three in the afternoon. The servant saw her. She must have driven
down here straight after that.
‘Mrs de Winter had an appointment to have her hair done,’ said Mrs
Danvers. ‘I remember that, because I telephoned to London for
her.Twelve until ! .30. She had lunch at her club after that.’
‘Say it took her half an hour to have lunch; what was she doing from
two o’clock until three?’
‘Oh, who cares what she was doing?’ shouted Favell. ‘She didn’t
kill herself- that’s the only thing that matters.’
‘1 have her appointment book locked away in my room,’ said Mrs
Danven slowly. ‘She may have noted down her appointments for that
day. She was very careful in that way. She used to write everything
down, and then mark it with a cross when it was done.’
‘Well, de Winter; what do you say? Do you mind us seeing this
‘Of course not,’ said Maxim. ‘Why on earth should I?’ Once again I
saw Colonel Julyan give him that strange, quick look.
Mrs Danvers carhe back with a small red book. ‘I was right,’ she
said. ‘She had marked down her appointments, as I said.’
She gave the little book to Colonel Julyan. There was a long pause
while he looked down the page. There was something about that
moment that frightened me more than anything that had happened that
evening. I could not look at Maxim.
‘Ah!’ he said. His finger was in the middle of the page. Something
is going to happen, I thought; something terrible.‘Yes, here it is.“Hair
at twelve”, as Mrs Danvers said. And a cross beside it. She kept her
appointment, then. “Lunch at the club”, and a cross beside that. What
have we here, though? “Baker, two o’clock.” Who was Baker?’ He
looked at Maxim. Maxim shook his head. Then at Mrs Danvers.
‘Baker?’ repeated Mrs Danvers. ‘She knew no one called Baker. I’ve
never heard the name before.’
‘Well, here it is!’ said Colonel Julyan, giving her the little book. ‘
“Baker.” And she’s put a great cross beside it as though she
wanted to break the pencil. It looks as though she saw this Baker,
whoever he may have been. I believe if we knew who he was we
would get to the bottom of the whole affair. She had no enemy, no
one who had ever threatened her, no one she was afraid of?’ ‘Mrs
de Winter afraid? She was afraid of nothing and no one. Only one
thing ever worried her, and that was the idea of getting old, of
illness, of dying in her bed. She said to me many times, “When I go,
Danny, I want to go out quickly – like a light.’’That’s the only thing
that comforted me. They say drowning’s painless, don’t they?’
Then suddenly she gave a cry, ‘There’s something here – right at
the back, among the telephone numbers. “Baker: 0488.’’That’s aU.’
‘That’s his number all right,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘But why
didn’t she put the exchange?’
‘Try every telephone exchange in London!’ said FaveU.‘It will
only take you all night, and Max wants to play for time, don’t you.
Max? And so should I, if I were in your shoes!’
‘Could this mark beside the number possibly be an M?’
Mrs Danvers took the little book in her hands again. ‘It might
be. It’s not like her usual M, but she may have written it in a hurry.
Yes, it might be M.’
‘Well?’ said Maxim. ‘Something had better be done about it
Frank! Go through and ask the exchange for Mayfair 0488.’
I stood quite still. Maxim did not look at me. Frank went into
the Httle room. In a moment we heard him say: ‘Is that Mayfair
0488? Can you tell me if anyone of the name of Baker lives there?
Oh, I see. I’m so sorry. Yes, I must have got the wrong number.
Then he came back into the room. ‘Someone called Lady Eastleigh
lives at Mayfair 0488. They have never heard of Baker.’ FaveU gave great
shouts of laughter. ‘Go on! What’s the next exchange on the list?’
‘Try Museum,’ said Mrs Danvers.
‘What the devil does it matter who he was? If it was of any
importance, Danny would know. Rebecca had no secrets from her.’
‘The servant at Museum 0488 told me that he was a very well-known doctor — a women’s specialist.’
‘H’m,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘There must have been something
wrong with her after all, but it seems very strange that she didn’t
say anything even to you, Mrs Danvers.’
‘She was too thin,’ said Fivell. ‘I told her so, but she only
laughed. She said it suited her. Did it on purpose, I suppose, like all
these women. She probably went to Baker for advice about what
she should eat.’
‘I can’t understand it,’ said Mrs Danvers.‘Dr Baker. Why didn’t
she tell me? She used to tell me everything.’
‘Perhaps she didn’t want to worry you,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘She
made an appointment with him, and saw him, and was going to tell
you all about it that night.’
‘And the note to Mr Jack,’ said Mrs Danvers suddenly. “‘I have
something to tell you. I must see you”; she was going to tell him
‘I believe you’re right after all,’ said Favell. ‘The note and the
appointment do seem to go together. But what the devil was it all
about? That’s what 1 want to know. What was the matter with
The truth shouted in their ears and they did not understand. I
dared not look at them. I dared not even move.
‘It ought to be quite easy to find out,’ said Frank. ‘I can write and
ask him if he remembers an appointment last year with Mrs de
‘I don’t know if he would answer you,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘You
know what these doctors are. The only way to get anything out of
him would be to get de Winter to see him himself and explain
‘I’m ready to do whatever you suggest,’ said Maxim quiedy.
‘Anything for time, eh?’ said Favell. ‘A lot can be done in
twenty-four hours, can’t it? Trains can be caught, ships can sail,
planes can fly.’
1 saw Mrs Danvers look sharply from Favell to Maxim, and I
realized then that she had not known about Favell’s accusation. At
last she was beginning to understand. I could tell fixam the
expression on her face. It’s too late, I thought, she can’t do anything
to us now. She can’t hurt us any more. Maxim was talking to
‘What do you suggest?’ he said. ‘Shall I drive to this address in
‘He’s not going alone,’ said Favell with a short laugh.‘I have a
right to say that, haven’t I? Send him up with Inspector Welch and
I shan’t object.’’
If only Mrs Danvers would take her eyes away fix)m Maxim.
Frank had seen her now. He was watching her, confused and
anxious. I saw him look once more at the piece of paper in his hand,
on which he had written Dr Baker’s address. Then he too looked at
Maxim. I believe that he began to get some faint idea of the truth,
because he went very white and put the paper down on the table.
‘I don’t think there is any need to bring Inspector Welch into the
affair – yet,’ said Colonel Julyan. His voice was different harder. I
did not like the way he used the word ‘yet’. Why must he use it at
all? I did not like it. ‘If I go with de Winter, and stay with him the
whole time, and bring him back, will that satisfy you?’
Favell looked at Maxim, then at Colonel Julyan. ‘Yes,’ he said
slowly, ‘yes, I suppose so. But for safety, do you mind if I come too?’
‘No. Unfortunately, I think you haVe the right to ask that.’
‘I rather think this Dr Baker is going to prove my case after all,’
said Favell. He looked round at each one of us and began to laugh. I
think he too had understood at last the meaning of that visit to the
‘Well,’ he said, ‘what time are we going to start?’
‘Nine o’clock?’ said Colonel Julyan.
‘Nine o’clock,’ said Maxim.
‘How do we know he won’t run off in the night?’ asked FaveU.
‘He’s only got to slip round to the garage and get into his car.’
‘Is my word good enough for you?’ said Maxim, turning to
Colonel Julyan. And for the first time Colonel Julyan paused.
Maxim’s face went pale. ‘Mrs Danvers,’ he’ said slowly, ‘when Mrs
de Winter and I go to bed tonight will you come up yourself and
lock the door on the outside? And call us yourself, at seven in the
‘Yes, sir,’ said Mrs Danvers.
‘Very well, then,’ said Colonel Julyan shortly. ‘I don’t think
there is anything else we need to discuss tonight. 1 shall be here at
nine in the morning. You will have room for me in your car, de
‘Yes,’ said Maxim.
‘And Favell will follow us in his?’
‘Right on your tail, my dear Colonel, right on your tail.’ Colonel
Julyan came up to me and took my hand. ‘Good night,’ he said.
‘You know how I feel for you in all this; there’s no need for me to
tell you. Get your husband to bed early if you can. It’s going to be a
long day’ He held my hand a minute, and then he turned away. It
was strange the way he avoided my eye.
‘I suppose I’m not going to be asked to dinner?’ Favell said.
‘Never mind. I’m looking forward to tomorrow. Goodbye then, old
man. Pleasant dreams. Make the most of your night behind that
locked door.’ He turned and laughed at me, and then he went out
of the room. Mrs Danvers followed him. Maxim and I were alone.
I held out my arms to him and he came to me like a child. I put
my arms round him and held him. We did not say anything for a
‘We can sit together,’ he said, at last, ‘driving up in the car.’
‘Julyan won’t mind.’
‘We shall have tomorrow night, too,’ he said. TThey won’t do
anything immediately. Not for twenty-four hours perhaps.’
I remember every detail of that evening. The curtains had been
closed. It seemed strange to be sitting in the dining room and not
looking out onto the gardens. It was like the beginning of autumn.
Later, the telephone rang. I heard Beatrice at the other end. ‘Is
that you? We’ve been trying to get you. We saw the-evening
papers,’ she said. ‘The result of the inquiry was a terrible shock to
both Giles and myself. What does Maxim say about it?’
‘I think it was a shock to everybody,’ I said.
‘But, my dear, I can’t believe it:Why on earth would Rebecca
have killed herself? The most unlikely person in the world! There
must be a mistake somewhere.’
‘I don’t know.’
‘What does Maxim say? Where is he?’
‘People have been here;’ I said. ‘Colonel Julyan and others.
Maxim is very tired. We’re going up to London tomorrow.’
‘What on earth for?’
‘Something to do with the result. I can’t really explain.’
‘You ought to get it changed. Surely Colonel Julyan can do
something? What are Justices of the Peace for? Old Horridge must
have been mad. Why was she supposed to have done it? Someone
ought to get hold of Tabb. How can he tell whether
those holes in the boat were made on purpose or not? Giles says of
course it must have been the rocks.’
‘They seemed to think not,’ I said.
‘If only I could have been there! No one seems to have made any
effort. Is Maxim very upset?’
‘He’s tired. More tired than anything else.’
‘Tell him he must try to get the result of the inquiry changed. It’s
so bad for the family. I’m telling everybody here that it’s a mistake.
Rebecca would never have killed herself She wasn’t the type.’
‘It’s no use,’ I said.‘It’s too late. Please, Beatrice, don’t try to do
anything. It will only make things worse. Please, Beatrice, just
leave it alone.’
Thank God she had not been with us today! There was a sudden
noise on the telephone line. I heard Beatrice saying, ‘Hullo! Hullo!’
and then there was silence. I went back to the library. Irt a few
minutes the telephone began ringing again; I let it ring. l,went and
sat down at Maxim’s feet. It went on ringing. I did not move.
Maxim put his arms around me, and we kissed feverishly,
desperately, like lovers who have not kissed before.
Chapter 10 The Visit to Dr Baker
When I awoke the next morning, just after six o’clock, and got up
and went to the window, the grass was wet and the trees were
hidden in a white mist; the air was cold, with the smell of autumn.
As I knelt by the window looking down on to the rose garden, the
events of the day before seemed far away and quite unreal. Here at
Manderley a new day was starting; the creatures in the garden were
not concerned with our troubles. A blackbird ran across the rose
garden in quick, short rushes. A seabird hung in the air, silent and
alone, and then spread his wings wide and
floated down over the woods towards the Happy Valley. These things
continued; our worries and fears did not change them. No one
would’ever hurt Manderley. It would lie always in its hollow, guarded
by the woods, safe and secret, while the sea broke and ran and came
again over the white stones of the little bay below.
My case looked unfamiliar as I dragged it out of a cupboard. It
seemed so long since I had used it, yet it was only four months ago. In
one of the pockets was a ticket for a theatre in Monte Carlo. It might
have belonged to another age, another world. My bedroom began to
take on the appearance of every room’when the owner goes away –
empty, unloved. When I was halfway down the passage I had a strange
feeing that I must go back and look once more. I stood for a moment,
looking at the open cupboard, the empty bed, the tea on the table. I
wondered why they had the power to touch me, to sadden me, as
though they were children who did not want me to go away.
After breakfast, Frank arrived.‘Colonel Julyan is waiting down at
the gates,’ he said. TU be in the office all day, in case you telephone.
After you’ve seen Baker you may find you want me, up in London.’
‘Yes,’ said Maxim. ‘Yes, perhaps.’
‘It’s just nine now. You’re on time. It’s going to be sunny. You
should have a good run.’
‘We’d better be off,’ said Maxim. ‘Old Julyan will be getting
I climbed into the car beside Maxim. Frank shut the door.
‘You will telephone, won’t you?’ he said.
‘Yes, of course,’ said Maxim.
I looked back at the house. Frith was standing at the top of the steps,
and Robert just behind. My eyes filled with tears for no reason. I
turned away, so that nobody would see. Then Maxim started up the
car, and we turned the corner and the house was hidden from us.
We stopped at the gates and picked up Colonel Julyan. He
looke^l doubtful when he saw me.
‘It’s going to be a long day,’ he said.‘I don’t think you should
have attempted it. I would have taken care of your husband, you
‘I wanted to come,’ I said.
He did not say any more about it, but got in the back. ‘That man
Favell said he would pick us up at the crossroads. If he’s not there,
don’t wait; we would do much better without him.’
But when we came to the crossroads I saw the long green body
of his car, and my heart sank. 1 had thought he might not be on
time. He was sitting smoking at the wheel, hatless; he waved us on
when he saw us. I settled down in my seat for the journey ahead,
one hand on Maxim’s knee.
The green car kept close behind us. We came .to the edge of
London at about three o’clock. It was then that I began to feel tired;
the noise and the heat gave me a headache. It was hot.The streets
had that dusty look of August, and the leaves hung still on the dull
trees. There had been no rain here. There were too many people,
too much noise. The drive through London seemed endless. By the
time we were through it and out beyond Hampstead there was a
sound in my head like the beating of a drum, and my eyes were
burning. I wondered how tired Maxim was. He was pale, and there
were shadows under his eyes.
When we came to Barnet itself. Colonel Julyan made him stop
every few minutes. ‘Can you tell us where a house called Roselands
is? It belongs to a Dr Baker, who has retired and come to live here
recently’ Behind us came Favell, his low green car covered with
dust. It was a postman who pointed out the house in the end. A
square house, with no name on the gate, which we had already
passed twice. Maxim stopped the car at the side of the road. We sat
silently for a few moments.
‘Well, here we are,’ said Colonel Julyan, ‘and it’s exactly twelve
minutes past five. We shall catch them in the middle of their tea.’
We got out of the car, and Favell came up. We walked up the
drive to the front door, a strange little party. Colonel Julyan rang
the bell. A very young servant opened the door, and looked
surprised that there were so many of us.
‘Dr Baker?’ said Colonel Julyan.
‘Yes, sir; will you come in?’
She opened a door on the left, into a room which looked not
much used in summer. Favell examined a picture on the wall.
Colonel Julyan stood by the empty fireplace. Maxim and I looked
out of the window.
Then the door opened and a man came into the room. He was of
average height, rather long in the face, with a firm jaw. His hair was
‘Forgive me for keeping you waiting,’ he said, looking a little
surprised, as the servant had done, at seeing so many of us.‘I had to
run upstairs and wash. I was in the garden when the bell rang.
Won’t you sit down?’
I sat down in the nearest chair, and waited.
Tm so sorry to disturb you like this,’ said Colonel Julyan.‘My
name is Julyan. This is Mr de Winter – Mrs de Winter. – Mr Favell.
You may have seen Mr de Winter’s name in the papers recently.’
‘Oh?’ said Dr Baker. ‘Yes, yes — I suppose I have. Some inquiry
or other, wasn’t there? My wife was reading all about it.’
‘It was said at the inquiry that the first Mrs de Winter killed
herself,’ said Favell,‘which I say is completely out of the question.
Mrs de Winter was my cousin. I knew her very well. She would
never have done such a thing. She had no reason to. What we want
to know is, what the devil she came to see you about on the day she
‘You had better leave this to Julyan and myself,’ Maxim said quietly.
‘Dr Baker has not the faintest idea what you mean.’ He
turned to the doctor. ‘We have driven up to see you today because
we found your name and the telephone number of your old rooms
in my first wife’s appointment book. She seems to have been to see
you at two o’clock on the last day she ever spent in London. Could
you possibly check this for us?’
When Maxim had finished, Dr Baker shook his head. ‘I’m very
sorry,’ he said, ‘but I think you have made a mistake. I should have
remembered the name de Winter. I’ve never attended a Mrs de
Winter in my life.’
Colonel Julyan brought out the litde book.‘Here it is, written
down,’ he said. “Baker, two o’clock.” And a big cross beside it, to
show that the appointment was kept. And here is what looks like
your number. “Museum 0488.’”
Dr Baker examined it.‘That’s very strange. Yes, the number is
correct, as you say.’
‘Could she have some to see you, and given another name?’
‘Why, yes, that’s possible. It’s unusual, of course. I’ve never
encouraged that sort of thing: it doesn’t do us any good in the
‘Would you have any record of the visit among your papers?’
said Colonel Julyan.‘I know this is not normally done, but we do
feel that her appointment with you must be connected with hei>-’
‘-murder,’ said Favell, interrupting him.
Dr Baker opened his eyes wide. ‘I had no idea there was any
question of that,’ he said quietly. ‘Of course I’ll do anything in my
power to help you. If you’ll excuse me for a few minutes I will go
and look among my papers. There should be a record of every
appointment, and a description of the case.’ He went out.
‘Seems a good sort,’ said Colonel Julyan.
‘Why didn’t he offer us a drink?’ said Favell. ‘Keeps it locked up,
I suppose. I don’t think much of him. I don’t believe he’s going to
help us after all.’
Dr Baker came back into the room with books and a pile of
papers in his hands. He carried them over to the table. Tve brought
the collection for the last year,’ he said. ‘I haven’t been through
them since we moved. I only retired six months ago, you know.’ He
opened a book and began turning the pages. I watched him
helplessly. He would find it, of course. It was only a question of
minutes now, of seconds. ‘The seventh, eighth, tenth,’ he said. ‘The
twelfth, did you say? At two o’clock? Ah!’
We none of us moved. We all watched his face.
‘I saw a Mrs Danvers on the twelfth at two o’clock.’
‘Danny? What on earth-’ began Favell, but Maxim cut him short.
‘She gave a false name, of course,’ he said. ‘That was obvious from
the first. Do you remember the visit now. Dr Baker?’
But Dr Baker was already searching in his papers. He soon found
the notes, and read them rapidly. ‘Yes,’ he said. ‘Mrs Danvers; I
remember now.’ He put the papers down. ‘Of course,’ he said to
Maxim, ‘you realize that this is very unprofessional? But your wife
is dead, and I quite understand that the situation is unusual. You
want to know if I can suggest any reason why your wife might have
taken her life? I think I can. The woman who called herself Mrs
Danvers was very seriously ill.’
He paused. He looked at every one of us in turn.
‘I remember her perfectly well. She came to me a week before
the date you mentioned, and I took some X-ray photographs of her.
This second visit was to hear what the X-rays showed. I remember
her holding out her hand for them. “I want to know the truth,” she
said. “I don’t want you to be gende with me. Just teU me.’”
He paused and looked down at the notes. I waited. Why couldn’t
he finish with it and let us go? Why must we sit there, waiting, our
eyes on his face?
‘Well, she asked for the truth, and I let her have it. Some
people are better for it; hiding the facts does them no good. She
stood it very well. She said she had guessed it for some time.Then
she paid me and went out. I never saw her again.’
He closed the book and put the papers back in the pile.
‘The pain was still slight, but the growth was deep-rooted. In
three or four months’ time there would have been nothing to do
but try to kill the pain, and wait.There is nothing else anyone can
do in a case like that.’
No one said a word.
‘Of course she still looked a perfectly healthy woman. Rather
too thin, I remember, and rather pale; but then that’s the fashion
now. The X-rays showed a certain faulty development in some of
the organs, I remember, which meant she could never have had a
child, but that was nothing to do with the disease.’
I remember hearing Colonel Julyan speak, saying something
about Dr Baker being very kind to have taken so much trouble.
‘You have told us all we want to know,’ he said, ‘and if we could
possibly have a copy of your notes, it might be very useful.’
‘Of course, of course.’
‘We may not need it at all. But either de Winter or I will write.
Here is my card.’
‘I’m so glad to have been of use. It never entered my head that
Mrs de Winter and Mrs Danvers could be the same person.’
‘You’ll be returning to London, 1 imagine? Your best way is to
turn sharp left at the corner, then right by the church. After that
it’s a straight road.’
‘Thank you.Thank you very much.’
We came out onto the drive, and walked to the car. No one
spoke. Favell looked grey and shaken. ‘I never had the slightest
idea,’ he said. ‘She kept it a secret from everyone, even Danny.
What a terrible thing, eh? Not the sort of thing one would ever
connect with Rebecca. Do you people feel like a drink? This
business has really shocked me, and I don’t mind admitting it. My
God!’ He leaned up against the car, and shaded his eyes with his
‘Pull yourself together, man,’ said Colonel Julyan.
‘Oh, you’re all right! You’re fine!’ said Favell, standing up
straight and looking at Colonel Julyan and Maxim. ‘Baker will
supply what you want in black and white, free of cost, whenever
you send the word.’
‘Shall we get into the car and go?’ said Colonel Julyan.‘We can
make our plans as we drive.’
We got in, but Favell still leaned against the car.
‘I should advise you to get straight back to your flat and go to
bed,’ said Colonel Julyan, ‘and drive slowly. I may as well warn you
now that as a Justice of the Peace / have certain powers that will
prove effective if you are ever seen in the Kerrith area again. We
know how to deal with people like you, strange though it may
Favell was watching Maxim. He had lost the grey colour now,
and the old unpleasant smile was forming on his lips. ‘Yes, it’s been
a stroke of luck for you, Max, hasn’t it?’ he said slowly. ‘You think
you’ve won, don’t you? But the law can still get you, and so can I, in
a different way . ..’
Maxim started the engine. ‘Have you anything else to say?’ he
said. ‘Because if so you had better say it now’
‘No,’ said Favell.‘No. I won’t keep you.You can go.’ He stepped
back, with the smile still on his lips. The car slid forward. As we
turned the corner I looked back and saw him standing there,
watching us; as he waved his hand, he was laughing.
We drove on for a while in silence.Then Colonel Julyan spoke.
‘He can’t do anything,’ he said. ‘That smile and that wave were only
part of his pretence. They are all alike, his sort. He hasn’t a thread of
a case to bring now. Baker would wreck it. I always felt the solution
was connected with Baker. The vyay she never even
told Mrs Danvers. She knew something was wrong. Terrible!
Enough to send a young and lovely woman right off her head. I
suppose you never had any idea of this?’
‘No,’ said Maxim. ‘No.’
‘Of course some people always live in fear of a disease hke that.
Women especially. That must have been the case with your wife.
She had enough courage for everything except that. She could not
face pain. Well, she was spared that, at any rate.’
‘Yes,’ said Maxim.
‘I don’t think it would do any harm if I quietly let it be known
down in Kerrith that a London doctor has suggested an explanation.
In case people talk. You never can tell, you know. People are funny.
If they knew about Mrs de Winter it might make it a lot easier for
you. I don’t suppose the newspapermen will worry you any more,
that’s one good thing.You’ll find they’ll drop the whole affair in a
day or two.’We drove on southwards, and entered London once
more. ‘Half past six. What are you going to do? I’ve got a sister
living in St John’s Wood, and I think rU ask her to give me dinner,
then catch the last train down. I’m sure she would be Ъарру to see
you both as well.’
Maxim paused, and looked at me. ‘It’s very kind of you,’ he said,
‘but I think not. I must ring up Frank, and one thing and another. I
think we’ll have a quiet meal somewhere, and start off again
afterwards. We’ll spend the night at a hotel on the way down.’
‘Of course,’ said Colonel Julyan. ‘I quite understand.’
When we came to his sister’s house, Maxim said: ‘It’s impossible
to thank you for all you’ve done today.You know what I feel.’
‘My dear man. I’ve been only too glad.You must put the whole
thing behind you now. I’m pretty sure you won’t have any more
trouble from FaveU. If you do, I shall know how to deal with him.’
He got out of the car, collecting his coat and his map. ‘I should
get away for a bit. Take a short holiday. Go abroad, perhaps.’ He
cleared his throat. ‘It is just possible that certain little difficulties
might come up. From one or two people in the area. One never
knows, what Tabb has been saying, and so on.You know the old
saying? “Out of sight, out of mind.” If people are not there to be
talked about, the talk dies. It’s the way of the world.’
He stood for a moment, counting his things. Tve got everything,
I think; coat, cap, stick, map, all- complete. Well, goodbye, both of
you. Don’t get overtired. It’s been a long day.’ He turned in at the
gate and walked up the steps.
We drove away down the road and turned the corner. I leaned
back in my seat and closed my eyes. Now that we were alone again
and the anxiety was over, the feeling was one of almost unbearable
relief. When Maxim stopped, I opened my eyes. We were opposite
a little restaurant in a narrow street in Soho.
‘You’re tired. Empty and tired and fit for nothing. You’ll be
better when you’ve had something to eat. So shall I. We’ll go in
here and order dinner right away. I can telephone Frank too.’
We got out of the car. There was no one in the restaurant. It was
dark and cool. We went to a table in the corner.‘Favell was right
about wanting a drink,’ said Maxim.‘I want one too, and so do you.’
My drink was soft, warming, strangely comforting.
‘When we’ve had dinner we’ll drive very slowly and quietly. It
will be cool, too, in the evening. We’ll find somewhere on the road
to stay the night; then we can go on to Manderley in the morning.’
‘Yes,’ I said.
Maxim’s eyes looked large, and they were ringed with shadows.
They looked very dark against his white face.
‘How much of the truth do you think Julyan guessed?’
I watched him over my glass, but said nothing.
‘He knew,’ said Maxim slowly, ‘of course he knew.’
‘If he did, he’ll never say anything.’
‘No,’ said Maxim.
He ordered another drink. We sat silent and peaceful in our dark
‘I believe that Rebecca lied to me on purpose. She wanted me to
kill her. She planned the whole thing. That’s why she laughed.
That’s why she stood there laughing when she died.’
1 went on with my drink. It was all over. All settled. It did not
matter any more. There was no need for Maxim to look white and
‘It was her last joke – the best of them all. And I’m not sure she
hasn’t won, even now.’
‘What do you mean? How can she have won?’
‘I don’t know,’ he said. ‘I don’t know’ He finished his second
drink, then got up.‘I’m going to telephone Frank,’ he said.
I sat there in my corner; and soon the waiter brought me my
fish. It was hot, and very good. I had another drink, too. I smiled at
the waiter, and asked for some more bread in French, for no reason.
It was quiet and friendly in the restaurant. Maxim and I were
together; everything was over.
Soon Maxim came back again. ‘Well,’ I said, ‘how was Frank?’
‘Frank was all right. Something rather strange, though,’ Maxim said
slowly.‘He thinks that Mrs Danvers has gone. It seems she had been
packing up all day, and a man from the station came for her things.
Frith told Frank about it, and Frank told Frith to ask Mrs Danvers
to come to see- him at the office. He waited but she never came.
About ten minutes before I rang up. Frith telephoned Frank again
and said that there had been a long-distance telephone call for Mrs
Danvers at about ten past six. Soon after that, he found her room
empty. She must have gone straight out of the house and through
the woods. She never went past the ^ates.’
‘Isn’t it a good thing?’ I said. ‘It saves us a lot of trouble. We
would have had to send her away, in any case. I believe she
guessed, too. There was a look oh her face, that night. I kept
thinking of it, coming up in the car.’
‘I don’t hke it,’ said Maxim.‘I don’t like it.’
‘She can’t do anything. It was Favell who telephoned, of course.
He must have told her about Baker. He would tell her what Colonel
Julyan said about threatening us. They won’t dare to do it.’
‘I’m not thinking of that.’
‘What else can they do? We’ve got to do as Colonel Julyan said
— we’ve got to forget it. It’s all over, dear; it’s finished. Your fish
will get cold. Eat it — it will do you good. You need something
inside you.You’re tired.’ I was using the words he had used to me. I
felt better and stronger. It was I now who was taking care of him.
Things were going to be different in the future. With Mrs Danvers
gone, I would,learn how to run the house. People would come to
stay, and I would not mind. There would be the interest of seeing to
their rooms, arranging flowers and books, ordering the food. We
would have children. Surely we would have children.
‘Have you finished?’ said Maxim suddenly.‘I don’t think I want
any more. Only coffee. Black, very strong, please – and the bill,’ he
added to the waiter.
I wondered why we must go so soon. It was comfortable in the
restaurant, and there was nothing to take us away. I liked sitting
there, with my head against the back of the chair, planning the
future in a lazy, pleasant way. I could have gone on sitting there for
a long while.
‘Listen,’ said Maxim, ‘do you think you could sleep in the car if I
wrapped you up and put you in the back? There’s a cushion there,
and my coat as well. I have a feeling I must get down tonight. We’ll
be there by half past two.’
‘You’ll be terribly tired.’
‘No,’ He shook his head. ‘I shall be all right. I want to get
home. Something’s wrong. I know it is.’ His face was anxious,
strange, as he began arranging things in the back of the car.
‘What can be wrong?’ I said. ‘It seems so strange to worry now,
when everything’s over. I can’t understand you.’
He did not answer. He covered me with his coat. It was very
comfortable. Much better than I imagined. I settled the cushion
under my head.
‘Are you all right? Are you sure you don’t mind?’
‘No,’ I said, smiling. ‘I’m all right. Much better to do this and get
home. We’ll be at Manderley long before sunrise.’
He got in, and we started on our journey. I shut my eyes. The
car moved smoothly. A hundred pictures came to my mind, mixed
together in a senseless pattern. Ben smiling foolishly; Mrs Danvers
standing at the top of the stairs in her black dress; the postman who
had pointed out the house to us today; Jasper chasing across the
grass. I fell into a strange, broken sleep, waking now and then to
the reality of my bed in the car and the sight of Maxim’s back in
front of me. There were the lights of passing cars on the road; there
were villages with lights behind closed curtains. At last 1 sat up,
and pushed the hair away from my face,
‘I can’t sleep,’ I said. ‘It’s no use.’
‘You’ve been sleeping,’ said Maxim. ‘You’ve slept for hours. It’s
quarter past two. We’ll soon be in Kerrith.’
It was cold. I was trembling in the darkness of the car. ‘I’ll come
beside you,’ I said. ‘We’ll be at Manderley by three.’
I climbed over and sat beside him, I put my hand on his knee, ‘You’re
cold,’ he said.
The hiUs rose in front of us, disappeared, and rose again. It was
quite dark, The stars had gone.
‘What time did you say it was?’ I asked.
‘Twenty past two.’
‘It’s funny – it looks almost as though day were breaking over
there, beyond those hills. It can’t be, though; it’s too early.’
‘It’s the wrong direction.You’re looking west.’
‘I know,’ I said. ‘It’s funny, isn’t it?’
He did not answer, and I went on watching the sky. It seemed to
get lighter even as’l looked. Like the first red light of sunrise. Little,
by little, it spread across the sky.
‘It’s in the winter you see the northern lights, isn’t it?’ I said.
‘Not in the summer?’
‘That’s not the northern lights,’ he said. ‘That’s Manderley.’
I looked at him and saw his face. I saw his eyes.
‘Maxim!’ I said.‘What is it?’
He drove much faster. We came to the top of the hifi: there to
the left of us was the silver thread of the river, widening towards
its mouth at Kerrith, ten kilometres Iway.The road to Manderley
lay ahead. There was no moon. The sky above our heads was inky
black. But the sky on the horizon was not black at all. It was red,
like blood. And the ashes blew towards us with the salt wind firam
Before you read
1 Read the Introduction and find answers to these questions, a
Who is Rebecca?
b What has happened to her? c Who teiis the story? d What is
Manderiey? e Who is the owner of Manderiey? f Who Is the
housekeeper’at Manderiey? . g Who manages the owner’s
business affairs? h Where does the owner of Manderiey meet
his new wife?
2 Find these words in your dictionary. They are all in the story.
bay cottage disturb misery scorn weed Which word can
a great unhappiness b negative
opinion of other people c a wild plant
d an area of the sea e to interrupt or
annoy someone f a small house
3 Complete these sentences with the new words from Exercise 2.
a No one looked after the garden. There were……………… … everywhere,
b The boat sailed into the beautiful ……………….of Naples.
c The sound of thunder……… …… the baby’s sleep,
d The old man’s …………….was deep and painful after his wife died.
e Her look of ………………… told me everything. She was secretly
laughing at me.
f The young couple’s dream was to live in a little …………………….. … .in a
After you read
4 Who or what is being described?
a Light came from the windows, the curtains blew softly in the night
a i r . . .
b … short straight hair and young, unpowdered f a c e . . . c Her interest
in other people was like a disease, d … it is a fever, and a misery too,
whatever the poets may say. a … someone tall and thin, dressed in
black, with great dark eyes if) a white face.
f There was blue paper on the walls, and there were different curtains.’
g ‘You never know what’s going on in that funny mind of his.’ h ’He
knows his own way back.’
5 Discuss what you know about Rebecca.
e What possible reasons are there for these words of Maxim’s?
‘We ought never to have come back to Manderley. Oh God, what a fool I
was to come backi’
Before you read
7 Write questions that you think will be answered In the next three
8 Oheck the meanings of these words in your dictionary:
fkncy dress modesty
How would you translate these words into your language? Answer ftese
a When do people in your country wear fancy dressf?
Ь Give some examples of clothes that people wear to fancy dress
8 When are people your age expected to act modestl/f d: What do you
think false modesty means?
After you read
a the ways in which Maxim’s second wife thinks she is not as good as
b the qualities that Frank Crawley thinks are important in a wife, c how
Maxim, Captain and Mrs Lacy and Frank Crawley react when Maxim’s
second wife comes down the stairs for the fancy- dress dance.
a how Rebecca died, b why Ben was frightened of Rebecca, c why
Maxim does not want Jack Favell at Mandertey. d why Mrs Danvers Is
so helpful about the fancy-dress dance.
11 Describe Rebecca’s room at Manderley.
12 Imagine you are Maxim de Winter. Describe to your sister your feelings
when your wife came down the stairs at the fancy-dress dance.
Before you read
13 How does Maxim’s second wife feei at this stage of the story? What do
you think wiil happen next?
14 Use your dictionary to chock the meaning of these words. Match the
words with the sentences beiow.
cliff Colonel Inspector
a You might meet this man at a meeting about careers in the army.
b This man’s office is in the police station, c You would have a good
view of the sea from here.
After you read
15 Answer these questions;
a Where is Rebecca’s boat found? b Who finds It?
с What is discovered on the fioor of the boat?
d How did water enter the boat?
a why Maxim stayed with Rebecca, b why Rebecca went to the
cottage so often, c the ‘deal’ that Maxim had with Rebecca, d what
finally persuaded Maxim to kill Rebecca.
• how Maxim tried to hide Rebecca’s body, f why Tabb, the boatbuilder,
wanted to examine Rebecca’s boat. 17 Work in pairs and take the parts of
Maxim and his second wife as Maxim tells her what really happened on the
night Rebecca was kilied, and she discovers that he never really loved
Before you read
16 Use the 9hapter headiri^s to guess what happens in the last part of the
Favell Accuses Maxim What does he accuse him of?
What proof can he give to support his accusation?
The Visit to Dr Baker Who is Dr Baker?
Why is he important to the story?
Will the police discover the true facts about Rebecca’s death?
19 Check the meanirjgs of these words in your dictionary. relief X-ray
Mark each phrase R for reliefer X for X-ray. a Done by a machine b An
emotion or feeling c After a frightening experience d Can be done in a
hospital or at an airport a A type of picture
f Money for the poor; food for the hungry
After you read
20 Who is speaking to whom, and what are they talking about?
a ‘it was arranged yesterday. The inquiry doesn’t make any difference.’
b ’… I can make things very unpleasant for you if L choose.’ c ‘I
never seen you.’
d ’ . . . I want to go out quickly – like a light.’ e ‘There is nothing
else anyone can do in a case like that.’ f ‘You think you’ve won,
don’t you?’ g ‘That’s why she iaughed.’ h ‘That’s not the northern
21 Discuss what you think happened to Manderley and why, and the effect
on Maxim and his wife.
Compare Maxim’s reiationships with his first and second wives. Imagine
you are Mrs Van Hopper’s companion at the beginning of the story. Write
a letter to her explaining why you are leaving your job.
Write Frank’s reply to someone who is thinking about employing Mrs
Danvers and has asked for his opinion.
You are a newspaper reporter. Write a report about the inquiry for the
next day’s paper.
Imagine you were standing on the cliffs above the cottage and the bay on
the night of Rebecca’s death and witnessed the whole event. Write a
statement for the police describing what you heard and saw that night.
Why does’Max’s second wife protect him? Would you do the same in her
Amwen for the Activities in this book are published in our free resource packs for teachers. Penguin Readcn
Factsheets, or available on a separate sheet. Please write to your local PeartOft Education office or to:
Marketing Department, Penguin Longman Publishing, 5 Bentinck Sotet, London W1M5RN.